The Open Boat: Who Perished At Sea?

In Stephen Crane's short story, 'The Open Boat', the only character to die is Billie, the oiler. After 30 hours stranded at sea, the four men in the boat attempt to swim to shore. Billie, the physically strongest of the group, swims ahead of the others but drowns when the boat capsizes. His death underscores the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate, highlighting the power of nature's indifference to the struggle of humankind.

Billie the oiler drowns as the boat capsizes near the shore

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", the only character to die is Billie the oiler. The story is based on Crane's own experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida. In both real life and the story, Crane and three other men were forced to navigate their way to shore in a small boat.

In the story, the men spend thirty hours in the boat, during which time they are exhausted, cold, and hungry. They bicker with one another but also form a sense of brotherhood. They see a lighthouse and a man on the shore, but their hopes of rescue are repeatedly dashed. Eventually, they decide to abandon the boat and swim to shore. Billie, who is the strongest of the four, swims ahead of the others. However, when the others reach the shore, they find Billie's body washed up on the beach.

The cause of Billie's death is not explicitly stated, but it is implied that he drowns when the boat capsizes near the shore. This interpretation is supported by the fact that, in real life, the boat carrying Crane and the other men overturned in the surf, forcing them to swim to shore. One of the men, an oiler named Billie Higgins, drowned.

Billie's death underscores the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate. It highlights the power of nature over human struggle and the indifference of nature to human life. The fact that Billie is the strongest of the four men and the only one to perish also suggests a form of reverse Darwinism, or the non-survival of the fittest.

His death underscores the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate

The Open Boat, a short story by Stephen Crane, is a powerful narrative of survival, nature's indifference, and the random hand of fate. The story's tragic ending, where one of the four men perishes, emphasizes the themes of naturalism and the unpredictability of destiny. The death of the correspondent, a seemingly random and arbitrary event, serves as a stark reminder of the story's underlying philosophical message.

The correspondent, a journalist, is one of the four men adrift at sea, struggling to survive. His death is sudden and unexpected, and it comes at a point in the story where there seems to be a glimmer of hope for the men. As they approach the shore, having endured the harsh conditions of the open sea, it appears they might make it to safety. However, in a cruel twist of fate, the correspondent drowns just a few yards from the beach.

This tragic ending underscores the story's naturalistic themes. Naturalism, as a literary movement, often explores the power of nature over human beings and the idea that humans are subject to the same laws of nature as any other creature. In The Open Boat, the sea is an indifferent and uncaring force, neither malicious nor benevolent. It simply exists, and the men's struggles are insignificant in the face of its vast power. The correspondent's death is a stark illustration of this power dynamic—despite their efforts, the men are ultimately at the mercy of nature.

Furthermore, the random and arbitrary nature of the correspondent's death highlights the theme of the randomness of fate. Throughout the story, Crane suggests that human lives are governed by chance and circumstance, rather than any divine plan or inherent meaning. The men find themselves in their perilous situation due to a series of unfortunate events, and their survival or death seems to hinge on random factors beyond their control. The correspondent's drowning is a stark example of this randomness—it could have been any one of them, and the fact that it was him seems almost absurdly arbitrary.

The correspondent's death also serves as a commentary on the fragility of human life and the fleeting nature of existence. In the face of the vast and indifferent sea, the men's lives hang by a thread, and their struggles and hopes are ultimately fleeting. The story's tragic ending leaves the reader with a sense of the profound uncertainty and unpredictability of life, reinforcing the naturalistic themes.

In conclusion, the death of the correspondent in The Open Boat is a powerful and poignant moment that underscores the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate. Through this tragic event, Crane emphasizes the indifference of nature, the fragility of human life, and the ultimately arbitrary nature of our existence. The correspondent's death serves as a stark reminder of the unpredictable and often cruel hand that fate can deal.

The indifference of nature to the men's struggle is a central theme

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", the only character who dies is Billie, the oiler. This, despite him being the physically strongest of the four men on the boat and having vast experience at sea.

The men must fight against nature for their survival, navigating their tiny lifeboat through rough waters. This process drains them of their energy and spirit, leaving them like "mummies". They are at the mercy of nature, and their illusion of control over it is shown to be false. The men are branded by nature, just as humans brand animals on land to demonstrate their power:

> The spray, when it dashed uproariously over the side, made the voyagers shrink and swear like men who were being branded.

The narrator notes that nature has the power to drown humans, and all a person can do in the face of this threat is shake his fist at the clouds and curse his fate. The men are at the mercy of five oceans, and the sea has complete control over them.

The indifference of nature is further emphasised when a seagull lands on the captain, and he is unable to shoo it away for fear of capsizing the boat. The bird sits on his head for as long as it likes, and the captain must reluctantly bear it.

Nature is as randomly helpful as it is hurtful. For every malevolent act, there is an unexpected good turn, such as a favourable wind or a calm night. This destroys the notion of nature as an entirely hostile force. Ultimately, nature is indifferent to the men—neither in favour of nor against them. Elements of nature both help and hinder their progress toward shore:

> A changed tide tried to force them southward, but the wind and wave said northward.

The waves' temperament shifts constantly, without any regard for the words and actions of the four men. A large wave capsizes the boat, setting in motion the events leading up to the oiler's death, but another large wave propels the correspondent safely to shore. Nature's indifference continues after they reach land, as the "indifferent shore" offers safety and survival for some, and the "sinister hospitality of the grave" for the oiler.

The correspondent realises that nature is not "cruel", "beneficent", "treacherous", or "wise". Instead, it is "indifferent, flatly indifferent", and humans are insignificant and small in comparison to nature's vastness.

The men's inability to save those stranded on the sinking ship

The short story "The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane is based on his experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida in 1896. Crane and three other men were forced to navigate their way to shore in a small boat after their ship, the SS Commodore, sank. The four men in the dinghy were the captain, an injured and morose man; the cook, a heavy, out-of-shape man; the correspondent, a journalist more used to intellectual labour; and the oiler, Billie, a young, physically strong man with vast experience at sea.

The men were unable to save those stranded on the sinking ship. As the ship went down, the cook let go of the line, and the dinghy rowed around in a futile attempt to get a line from the chief engineer. There were no screams or cries, just silence, and then the ship sank. The dinghy's occupants were unable to help those left on the ship, and could only watch as the Commodore disappeared beneath the waves.

Crane's personal account of the shipwreck, published a few days after his rescue, dedicates just two paragraphs to the fate of the men in the dinghy, focusing instead on the sinking of the ship and the ensuing chaos. The dinghy was overwhelmed by the "frightful maw of the ocean", and the men were forced to witness the rafts being "swallowed" by the sea. Their inability to save those on the ship left them shocked and devastated, with the correspondent noting that "words were still not words—something far beyond words".

The men in the dinghy were left to battle the elements and try to survive. Despite their efforts, only three of them made it to shore alive. Billie, the oiler, drowned as the boat capsized near the shore, his death underscoring the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate. His strength and efforts could not save him from the indifferent power of nature, highlighting the futility of human struggle against the forces of the sea.

The men's optimism evaporates when they realise no help is coming

As they approach land, the men are exhausted and bitter. They have been fighting against the relentless waves, struggling to keep their small boat from capsizing. The correspondent and the oiler have been taking turns rowing, while the cook bails water to keep them afloat. Despite their efforts, they are unable to master the turbulent surf.

Their hopes had been raised earlier when they spotted a lighthouse in the distance and thought they saw a man on shore. They had desperately sought signs of rescue, even thinking they saw a crowd and a boat being rolled down to the shore. But now, as they draw closer, they realise that no help is coming.

The men are faced with the harsh reality that they are alone and vulnerable in the face of nature's power. Their earlier optimism has been replaced by bitterness and despair. They are forced to turn back out to sea, their strength waning. The correspondent wonders how he can have come so far only to drown.

The men's sense of brotherhood, which had sustained them through their ordeal, is now tested as they confront the possibility of their impending death. The correspondent recalls a poem from his childhood about a soldier dying in a distant land, never to return home. The men are faced with the randomness of fate, their fate resting on the indifferent power of nature.

Frequently asked questions