Gel Cell Batteries: Better Boat Battery Option?

When it comes to choosing a battery for your boat, there are several factors to consider. The type of battery you need depends on the specific needs of your boat and how it is equipped. The market offers a variety of options, from traditional flooded cell batteries to AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) and Gel Cell batteries, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. While AGM batteries are widely used and known for their low maintenance, deep cycling capability, and resistance to leaks and acid spills, Gel Cell batteries stand out for their high performance, sturdiness, and ability to be placed in various positions. However, Gel Cell batteries are more sensitive to recharge voltages and require careful calibration to avoid premature failure. Ultimately, the decision between AGM and Gel Cell batteries depends on factors such as the type of boat, usage patterns, and the presence of compatible charging systems.

Gel batteries are sealed valve-regulated and require no maintenance

Gel batteries are a great choice for boats because they are sealed valve-regulated, require no maintenance, and have a very low self-discharge rate. Being sealed valve-regulated means that they are spill-proof, even if the battery case cracks or breaks. This is achieved through the use of a gelled type of electrolyte, where the sulfuric acid is blended with a form of fumed silica, resulting in a gel-like substance that is immobile. This unique design means that gel batteries do not need to stand upright and can be placed on their side or upright. They can even be built into a semi-dry bilge, solving battery space problems. However, placing them on their side or end may result in a loss of performance of up to 10%.

Gel batteries are also maintenance-free. Their recombination technique replaces the lost moisture in the battery as long as the integrity of the closed cell is maintained. This is in contrast to traditional flooded lead-acid batteries, which require regular maintenance and are more fragile. Gel batteries are also sturdier and more forgiving when it comes to impacts.

One of the standout features of gel batteries is their extremely low self-discharge rate. While flooded-cell batteries self-discharge at a rate of 1% per day or 30% per month, gel batteries typically self-discharge less than 2% per month. This makes gel batteries ideal for boats that are used infrequently or stored for long periods.

However, it is important to note that gel batteries are very sensitive to overcharging. They should never be subjected to a recharge voltage greater than 14.7 volts, and some manufacturers recommend no more than 14.1 volts for any sustained period. Overcharging can lead to oxygen and hydrogen loss via the cap, resulting in a dried-out cell. Therefore, it is crucial to use a charger that is specifically designed for gel batteries or has adjustable voltage levels. Additionally, gel batteries are known to be finicky when it comes to recharging, and users have reported issues with finding compatible marine battery chargers.

In summary, gel batteries are an excellent choice for boat batteries due to their sealed and maintenance-free design, low self-discharge rate, and sturdy construction. However, their sensitivity to overcharging and the need for specific chargers are important considerations when deciding whether to opt for gel batteries over other types, such as AGM or flooded lead-acid batteries.

They can be placed on their side or upright

When it comes to gel cell batteries, one of their standout features is their versatility in terms of placement. Unlike traditional flooded-cell batteries, gel cell batteries can be placed on their side or upright without any adverse effects on performance or function. This is because gel cell batteries are sealed and use a gelled type of electrolyte, which means they don't need to stand upright to prevent leaks.

This unique design characteristic of gel cell batteries makes them a popular choice for boat owners as it provides flexibility in terms of installation and battery storage options. Whether placed on their side or upright, gel cell batteries can deliver reliable performance. This is especially advantageous for boats with limited space, as the batteries can be positioned in various orientations to maximise space utilisation.

It is worth noting that while gel cell batteries can be placed on their side, some manufacturers and experts suggest that this may result in a slight loss of performance. For example, Darrell Nicholson, in his article for Practical Sailor, mentions that placing a gel battery on its side could lead to up to a 10% loss of performance. However, this reduction in performance is relatively minor and may not be a significant concern for most boat owners.

The ability to place gel cell batteries on their side or upright also enhances their safety. As these batteries are sealed and non-spillable, even if the battery case cracks or breaks, the gelled electrolyte will not spill out. This feature provides peace of mind, especially in marine environments where rough seas or accidental impacts could potentially damage traditional batteries.

In summary, the versatility of gel cell batteries in terms of placement is a significant advantage. Their ability to be positioned on their side or upright without compromising performance or safety makes them a compelling option for boat owners. This flexibility, combined with their other benefits, such as low maintenance and excellent deep cycling capability, contributes to their popularity in the marine industry.

They are finicky when it comes to being recharged

Gel cell batteries are indeed finicky when it comes to being recharged. They require a well-regulated charging system and are extremely sensitive to charge voltages above 14.1 volts DC at 68 degrees. If the voltage goes higher than this, the battery will be damaged.

Gel cells are also sensitive to voltages below this threshold. They should never be subjected to a recharge voltage of less than 13.8 volts DC, at 68 degrees. This is because, during the cool-down phase of the gel cell's chemical reaction, tiny hairline cracks form between the gel and the battery's plates. Oxygen and hydrogen gases combine in these cracks to produce water, which is then absorbed by the gelled electrolyte. If the voltage is too low, this process will not occur, and the battery will not recharge.

Therefore, it is important that the voltage is carefully regulated within this narrow range. If you don't have a voltage-regulated, three-stage battery charger with temperature compensation, or an alternator with a three-step regulator, you should only expect to get about half of the battery's rated life cycle.

Additionally, the specific voltage requirements vary from manufacturer to manufacturer, and these requirements must be strictly adhered to. This means that gel cell batteries are not user-friendly and can be difficult to align with the correct marine battery charger.

However, despite these drawbacks, gel cell batteries do have some advantages. They recharge much faster than flooded-cell batteries, provided that the regulated charge voltage is temperature-compensated and falls within the correct range. They also have an extremely low self-discharge rate, which can be advantageous when laying up a vessel at the end of the season.

They are more expensive than traditional flooded cell batteries

Gel cell batteries are more expensive than traditional flooded cell batteries. The cost of gel batteries has to be weighed against their benefits. They are sealed-valve-regulated, meaning they will vent, but only under overcharging if excess pressure builds up. They require essentially zero maintenance and have excellent deep-cycling capability. They also have a very low self-discharge rate of 3% per month.

However, gel-cell batteries are very particular about their recharge regimen. They should never be subjected to a recharge voltage greater than 14.7 volts, and some vendors state no more than 14.1 volts for any sustained period. This is a problem because internal voltage regulators on engine-driven alternators typically produce in excess of 15 volts. Therefore, if a boat is already equipped with an engine-driven alternator, an upgrade will be required to use gel-cell batteries. A programmable regulator will need to be installed in the system and set appropriately.

Additionally, any solar- or wind-charging units must be run through a charge controller that can handle the lower voltages required by gel batteries. The shore-power charger will also need to have a gel-cell setting or adjustable voltage levels for its various charging phases. All of these requirements will add to the overall cost of gel-cell batteries.

AGM batteries, another alternative to traditional flooded cell batteries, are also more expensive. However, they are more forgiving when it comes to charging and discharging. They can withstand continued deep-cycling and higher regulated voltages better than gel-cell batteries. They also do not require the same level of upgrades to a boat's charging system as gel-cell batteries. Therefore, AGM batteries may be a more cost-effective option for those seeking to replace traditional flooded cell batteries.

They have a very low self-discharge rate

One of the most significant advantages of gel cell batteries is their extremely low self-discharge rate. This means that they can retain their charge for extended periods, even when not in use. This feature makes them ideal for boats that may sit idle for long periods without sailing. The self-discharge rate of gel cell batteries is significantly lower than that of flooded-cell batteries, which can self-discharge up to 30% per month. With a gel cell battery, boat owners can rest assured that their battery will maintain its charge and be ready for use when needed, even after prolonged periods of inactivity.

The low self-discharge rate of gel cell batteries is attributed to their unique construction. The gelled electrolyte within the battery, which has the consistency of petroleum jelly, prevents the escape of hydrogen and oxygen gases during normal operation. This design prevents the battery from losing its charge over time, ensuring that it remains active and functional even during storage or when the boat is not in use. This feature is particularly advantageous for boat owners who may not use their vessels regularly or those who take extended breaks from sailing.

Additionally, gel cell batteries are known for their durability and resistance to external factors. They can withstand rough seas and vibrations better than traditional flooded-cell batteries due to the pressing together and inherent rigidity of the gel in the gel cell case. This makes them a reliable choice for boats operating in challenging conditions or navigating through rough waters. Their sturdy construction also contributes to their low self-discharge rate, as they are less susceptible to damage or performance degradation over time.

It is worth noting that gel cell batteries have specific charging requirements and are sensitive to charge voltages above 14.1 volts DC. Boat owners considering gel cell batteries should ensure that their charging systems are compatible and properly calibrated to avoid damaging the batteries. This may involve upgrading to a programmable voltage regulator or ensuring that shore power chargers have gel cell settings or adjustable voltage levels.

In summary, gel cell batteries offer a very low self-discharge rate, making them ideal for boats that may sit idle for extended periods. Their unique construction and sealed design prevent gas escape and maintain the battery's charge. However, it is crucial to ensure proper charging procedures to avoid premature failure. With their low self-discharge rate and durability, gel cell batteries are a reliable option for boat owners seeking consistent and long-lasting performance.

Frequently asked questions