Detroit Diesel Engines: Fuel Efficiency On Water

The Detroit Diesel engine is a highly adaptable, versatile, and powerful engine that has been used in various applications, including buses, fire trucks, fishing boats, and work boats. It is known for its iconic sound and high speed, delivering more power at lower speeds compared to other engines. While the two-stroke Detroit Diesel engine is no longer in commercial production due to challenges in meeting modern emission regulations, it has left a lasting legacy in the marine industry.

When it comes to fuel efficiency, a well-maintained diesel engine typically burns around 0.4 pounds of fuel per hour for each unit of horsepower it produces. This results in lower fuel consumption compared to gasoline engines, which burn about 0.50 pounds of fuel per hour per unit of horsepower.

However, it's important to note that fuel efficiency can vary depending on various factors, such as the boat's drag, sea conditions, and efficiency losses through transmissions and bearings. Additionally, the Detroit Diesel engine's unique design and operating system may also impact its overall fuel efficiency.

In conclusion, while the Detroit Diesel engine has proven its reliability and power, its fuel efficiency depends on a range of factors and can be challenging to estimate.

Detroit Diesel's two-cycle engines are more fuel-efficient than four-cycle engines

Detroit Diesel two-cycle engines are more fuel-efficient than four-cycle engines. The Detroit Diesel engine is unique and offered by no other manufacturer. It utilizes a moderately heavy cylinder block that is quite complex in its casting. Compared to other engines, it is lighter, but compared to Yanmar or Cummins, it is heavy. It is a long-stroke, smaller-bore engine than most four-cycle engines. This gives the Detroit engine considerably higher torque at lower speed ranges, but limits its top RPM range. Thus, it achieves higher power at lower speeds.

The Detroit injector system is another major difference over four-cycle engines. The push rods of these engines are also about 33% longer than most four-cycle engines, creating more rotational mass and therefore more rotational torque. Altogether, the engine delivers more power from less displacement, lower speed, but higher casting weights, while fuel consumption remains approximately the same.

The Detroit Diesel engine has a unique fuel system. It has no fuel injector pump, but rather each injector is its own fuel pump. An injection pump is like a small engine with 6 or 8 cylinders and pistons that pump and supply fuel to the injector, which in a four-cycle engine is nothing more than a spray nozzle. On a Detroit Diesel engine, each injector is operated by dual underhead camshafts that are immediately below the head.

A Detroit Diesel engine uses its fuel as part of the cooling system for the cylinder head and injector. It returns a lot of fuel back to the tank, and it is very hot. Thus, a Detroit Diesel has a fuel oil cooler, whereas a four-cycle engine does not. With Detroits, one has to be careful about the state of fuel return to the tank when deciding to run off of one tank only. Detroits are mostly self-priming fuel systems. If air gets into the fuel system of a four-cycle engine, it won't run.

The Detroit Diesel engine is more fuel-efficient than a four-cycle engine because it achieves higher power at lower speeds, has a unique fuel system with self-priming injectors, and uses fuel as part of its cooling system.

Detroit Diesel engines are no longer in commercial production

The Detroit Diesel Engine, introduced in 1938, is a two-stroke engine that was used to power several heavy North American road vehicles, including buses, fire trucks, and other heavy equipment. It was also used extensively in marine applications, powering fishing boats and work boats. The Detroit Diesel Engine was a wartime workhorse, and its versatility and reliability made it extremely popular.

However, the production of the two-stroke Detroit Diesel Engine has been discontinued. The primary reason for this discontinuation is the challenge of bringing the engine into compliance with modern emission regulations. The two-stroke design, while offering excellent power-to-weight ratios, has fallen out of favour due to its environmental impact.

The Detroit Diesel Corporation (DDC) has shifted its focus to other types of engines, particularly four-cycle engines, which are cleaner and more fuel-efficient. In 1987, DDC introduced the Series 60 engine, which became the biggest-selling heavy-duty diesel engine in the North American Class 8 truck market. This shift towards more environmentally friendly and fuel-efficient engines led to the phasing out of the two-stroke Detroit Diesel Engine.

While the two-stroke Detroit Diesel Engine is no longer in commercial production, its impact and legacy are still felt today. These engines were known for their adaptability and longevity, and they played a crucial role in various industries, including transportation, military, and marine. Even today, there are almost 500,000 "Screamin' Jimmies" (as they are affectionately called) still in operation worldwide, with a total of 3.5 million two-stroke engines built since 1940.

Although the two-stroke Detroit Diesel Engine is no longer in production, its reputation for reliability and performance endures, and it remains a significant milestone in the history of engine design and development.

Detroit Diesel engines are more fuel-efficient at lower speeds

Detroit Diesel engines are unique in that they are the only manufacturer to produce two-cycle engines, which have more rotational mass and therefore more rotational torque than their competitors' four-cycle engines. This means that the Detroit Diesel engine delivers more power from less displacement, lower speed, and higher casting weights, while fuel consumption remains approximately the same.

The Detroit Diesel engine is a long-stroke, smaller bore engine than most four-cycle engines. This gives it considerably higher torque at lower speed ranges, but limits its top RPM range: the longer the stroke, the slower the engine has to run. Thus, higher power at lower speeds.

The Detroit injector system is another major difference. The push rods of these engines are about 33% longer than most four-cycle engines, creating more rotational mass and therefore more rotational torque.

The typical V-8 Detroit engine today has more than double the number of internal parts as, say, a Caterpillar V-8, making it a more sophisticated, yet remarkably not more costly, engine. This is because Detroit Diesel is the largest diesel engine manufacturer in the world, so they sell a lot of parts, and higher production means lower cost.

Detroit Diesel engines are also more fuel-efficient at lower speeds due to the fact that they are two-cycle engines. At slow speeds (below 1.3 times the square root of the waterline length), the boat sits fully in the water, riding between a wave at the bow and a wave at the stern. As soon as speed increases above this number, fuel burn rises sharply.

At cruising speeds, fuel consumption will be decreased. Engines with electronically-managed fuel injection and direct injection will yield higher fuel efficiency.

To summarise, Detroit Diesel engines are more fuel-efficient at lower speeds due to their unique design as two-cycle engines, which have higher torque and lower top RPM ranges than their four-cycle competitors.

Detroit Diesel engines are more fuel-efficient than gasoline engines

Detroit Diesel engines are known for their versatility and adaptability, and have been used in various applications, from powering heavy road vehicles to fishing boats and work boats. One of their most notable roles was in World War II, where they were used in landing craft to bring soldiers to the beaches on D-Day.

The two-stroke Detroit Diesel engines are no longer in commercial production due to challenges in meeting modern emission regulations. However, they have been replaced by more sophisticated and fuel-efficient four-stroke engines, such as the Detroit Diesel Series 60.

When it comes to fuel efficiency, a well-maintained diesel engine typically burns about 0.4 pounds of fuel per hour for each unit of horsepower it produces. In comparison, an in-tune four-stroke gasoline engine will burn about 0.50 pounds of fuel per hour per unit of horsepower.

To put this into context, let's consider a 300-horsepower engine. Using the formulas provided, we can estimate that a 300-hp diesel engine would consume approximately 16.6 gallons of fuel per hour at peak horsepower, while a 300-hp gasoline engine would consume about 24.5 gallons per hour.

It's important to note that these estimates are based on peak horsepower and may not reflect fuel consumption at cruising speeds, which would be lower. Additionally, factors such as drag, sea conditions, and efficiency losses through transmissions and bearings can further impact fuel efficiency.

In summary, Detroit Diesel engines, including the newer four-stroke models, offer greater fuel efficiency than gasoline engines. This makes them a popular choice for various applications, particularly in the commercial boat industry, where fuel efficiency and power are crucial.

Detroit Diesel engines are more fuel-efficient than engines from Caterpillar

Detroit Diesel engines are unique, and no other manufacturer offers an engine like it. The Detroit Diesel engine uses a two-cycle diesel engine, while Caterpillar uses a four-cycle engine. The Detroit Diesel engine delivers more power from less displacement, lower speed, and higher casting weights, while fuel consumption remains approximately the same. The Detroit Diesel engine is also more fuel-efficient due to its injector system. Each injector is its own fuel pump, which is operated by dual underhead camshafts. This allows for more precise fuel metering and makes the system more reliable and less sensitive to fouled fuel.

Additionally, Detroit Diesel engines have a strong presence in the North American market and are known for their reliability. They are also less expensive to maintain, as they are the largest diesel engine manufacturer in the world, selling a lot of parts at lower costs. Detroit Diesel engines are also versatile in terms of power ratings, allowing for a broad range of power ratings with relatively minor changes.

On the other hand, Caterpillar engines have a reputation for durability and performance, particularly in heavy equipment. They are known for their ACERT technology, which reduces emissions while maintaining performance. Caterpillar engines also have a global presence, with manufacturing facilities in several countries. However, they are more expensive to maintain, as they require special tooling that can only be purchased from the company.

Frequently asked questions