The Open Boat: Who Perished In The Waters?

In Stephen Crane's short story 'The Open Boat', the only character to die is Billie, the oiler. After 30 hours at sea, the four survivors of a shipwreck attempt to swim to shore. Billie, the strongest of the four, swims ahead but drowns when the boat capsizes. His death underscores the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate, highlighting the indifference of nature to the struggles of man.

The strongest crew member, Billie the oiler, drowns

In Stephen Crane's short story, "The Open Boat", the strongest crew member, Billie the oiler, drowns. This tragic event occurs as the small dinghy carrying four survivors of a shipwreck capsizes in the turbulent surf near the shore. Billie's death is particularly shocking and ironic given that he was the physically strongest of the group and had worked tirelessly to keep the boat afloat.

The story, based on Crane's own experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida, explores the themes of survival, solidarity, and the conflict between man and nature. The men in the boat, including Billie, the correspondent, the cook, and the captain, are forced to navigate their way to shore, facing exhaustion, the indifferent power of nature, and the overwhelming struggle for survival.

Despite their collective efforts, the small boat overturns in the powerful waves, and the men are forced to swim to shore. Billie, the strongest of the group, swims ahead, but tragically, his body is later found washed up on the beach. The randomness and injustice of his death underscore the story's themes of naturalism and the unpredictability of fate.

Billie's drowning highlights the indifference of nature towards human struggle. His death serves as a stark reminder that nature is arbitrary in choosing its victims, reinforcing the idea that survival is ultimately dependent on chance. The strongest among them perishes, challenging the notion of survival of the fittest and further emphasizing the powerlessness of humans in the face of nature's might.

The death of Billie, the only character whose name is given, adds a personal touch to the story. By naming Billie, Crane creates a sense of connection and empathy for the reader. As the only named character, Billie becomes a symbol of the fragility of human life and the unpredictable forces that govern it. His death leaves a profound impact, reminding us of the fleeting nature of existence and the relentless power of the sea.

Crane's personal experience of shipwreck inspired the story

In 1896, American author Stephen Crane boarded the steamship SS Commodore, which was headed from Jacksonville, Florida, to Cuba. Crane was hired as a war correspondent during the Cuban insurrection against Spain. The ship was carrying 27 or 28 men, as well as a cargo of supplies and ammunition for the Cuban rebels.

Less than two miles from Jacksonville, the Commodore struck a sandbar in a dense fog and damaged its hull. The ship was towed off the sandbar the following day, but it was again beached in Mayport, Florida, and further damaged. A leak began in the boiler room, and due to malfunctioning water pumps, the ship came to a standstill about 16 miles from Mosquito Inlet. As the ship took on more water, Crane described the engine room as resembling "a scene at this time taken from the middle kitchen of Hades."

Commodore's lifeboats were lowered in the early hours of 2 January 1897, and the ship sank at 7 a.m. Crane was one of the last to leave the ship in a 10-foot dinghy. He and three other men—an injured captain, Edward Murphy, the ship's steward, Charles B. Montgomery, and an oiler, William Higgins—floundered off the coast of Florida for a day and a half. They attempted to land their craft at Daytona Beach, but the small boat overturned in the surf, forcing the exhausted men to swim to shore. One of them, the oiler, drowned.

Crane's personal account of the shipwreck and the men's survival, titled "Stephen Crane's Own Story", was published a few days after his rescue. He subsequently adapted his report into a short story, "The Open Boat", which was published in Scribner's Magazine in 1898. The story is told from the point of view of an anonymous correspondent, with Crane as the implied author. It closely resembles the author's experiences after the shipwreck, including the men's realisation that nature is indifferent to their fates.

Crane's experience of shipwreck inspired not only "The Open Boat" but also several other works, including a syndicated article, "The Filibustering Industry"; the short story "Flanagan: And His Short Filibustering Adventure"; and poems such as "A Man Adrift on a Slim Spar".

Nature's indifference to the men's fate is a central theme

The story explores the dynamic between humankind and nature, with the four men representing humankind and their struggle for survival against the indifferent and uncontrollable forces of nature. Despite their efforts to prevail over nature, the men are at its mercy, and their tiny lifeboat is no match for the rough waters. The story deliberately challenges the notion of human dominance over nature, underscoring the idea that nature is indifferent to human struggle and fate.

As the men battle against the elements, their energy and spirits are drained, leaving them helpless and exhausted. They realise that nature is not on their side or against them but is instead ambivalent and indifferent to their plight. This is reflected in the correspondent's thoughts: "She [nature] did not seem cruel to him, nor beneficent, nor treacherous, nor wise. But she was indifferent, flatly indifferent." The correspondent's repeated phrase, "If I am going to be drowned," further emphasises the randomness and indifference of nature, highlighting the existential crisis faced by the characters.

The men's perceptions of nature also change throughout the story. Initially, they view nature as a hostile force set against them, but as the story progresses, they come to understand that nature is neither friend nor foe but simply indifferent. This is exemplified by the dual nature of the sea, which both helps and hinders their progress. The indifferent power of nature is further emphasised by the death of Billie, the strongest of the four men. His death underscores the theme of naturalism and the randomness of fate, as nature's indifference to human struggle is laid bare.

In "The Open Boat," Crane presents a harsh and unforgiving world where nature holds all the power, and humans are insignificant in the face of its vastness. The story's exploration of nature's indifference to the men's fate serves as a central theme, highlighting the characters' existential crisis and the ultimate futility of their struggle against the overwhelming forces of nature.

The men's solidarity and brotherhood

In Stephen Crane's short story, 'The Open Boat', four men are stranded at sea in a small dinghy after their ship, the SS Commodore, sinks. The men—an injured captain, a cook, a correspondent, and an oiler named Billie—are forced to work together to survive. Despite their differences, they form a strong bond of solidarity and brotherhood as they face the harsh realities of their situation.

The men's solidarity is evident in the way they depend on each other and work together to keep the boat afloat. The correspondent and the oiler take turns rowing, while the cook bails water. Even the injured captain contributes by giving directions and later helping to row. They also share what little they have, such as the four dry cigars the correspondent finds and distributes.

Their brotherhood is strengthened by their shared experience of facing an indifferent and unpredictable nature. The sea is described as a hostile and ambivalent force, indifferent to their struggles and fate. This is highlighted by the ironic death of Billie, the strongest and hardest-working member of the group, who drowns when the boat capsizes near the shore. His death underscores the randomness of fate and the powerlessness of humans against the forces of nature.

The men's solidarity is also reflected in the way they face their mortality. As they confront the possibility of death, they find comfort and strength in their shared experience. The correspondent, for example, expresses his frustration and anger at the idea of drowning, highlighting their shared sense of helplessness. The men's bond is further strengthened as they make the difficult decision to abandon the dinghy and swim for shore, a decision that ultimately leads to Billie's death.

Throughout their ordeal, the men's solidarity and brotherhood provide them with the strength and resilience to persevere in the face of adversity. Their shared experience and dependence on each other create a unique and powerful bond that helps them survive the physical and mental challenges of their situation.

The story's existential crisis and sense of futility

"The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane is a short story based on the author's experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida. In January 1897, Crane was stranded at sea for thirty hours when the ship he was travelling on, the SS Commodore, sank after hitting a sandbar. Crane and three other men were forced to navigate their way to shore in a small boat, but one of them, an oiler named Billie Higgins, drowned after the boat overturned.

The story explores themes of survival, solidarity, and the conflict between man and nature. It is told from the point of view of an anonymous correspondent and is considered an exemplary work of literary Naturalism. The correspondent regularly refers to the sea with feminine pronouns, pitting the four men in the boat against an intangible, yet effeminate, threat.

The existential crisis and sense of futility in the story are evident in the characters' struggle against the overwhelming forces of nature. The repetition of the phrase, "If I am going to be drowned," highlights the randomness and indifference of nature, underscoring the helplessness and futility of the men's struggle. The correspondent's sense of frustration and rage at his utter helplessness is apparent as he grapples with the idea that his survival depends solely on chance.

The death of Billie, the oiler, further underscores the story's themes of naturalism and the randomness of fate. As the strongest and most physically able of the four characters, his death highlights the indifference of nature towards man and the arbitrariness of its victims. It reinforces the idea that nature is ultimately disinterested in human struggles and reinforces the sense of futility in the face of its overwhelming power.

The characters' inability to rely on a higher power or being for protection adds to the existential crisis. The correspondent laments the lack of religious support and his inability to blame God for his misfortunes, expressing a sense of isolation and abandonment. The metaphysical conflicts born from man's isolation are prevalent throughout the story, contributing to the overall sense of existential dread and futility.

Facing an indifferent and detached nature, the characters find solace in human solidarity. They are often referred to collectively as "the men," creating a silent understanding and a bond of togetherness. Their shared experience of fear and anxiety brings them closer, and they find strength in their unity. However, even this solidarity cannot protect them from the capriciousness of nature, as they are at its mercy throughout their ordeal.

Frequently asked questions