Heet Treatment For Non-Ethanol Boat Fuel: Good Or Bad?

Ethanol is a common fuel additive derived from corn or other plant materials. It is added to gasoline to increase its oxygen content, improve combustion, and reduce emissions. However, its use in boat fuel is controversial due to its hygroscopic nature, which can lead to water absorption and condensation in fuel tanks, potentially causing engine damage and corrosion. HEET is a fuel additive that contains isopropyl alcohol, which, like ethanol, can absorb water and allow the engine to burn it. This article will explore the pros and cons of using HEET in non-ethanol boat fuel, considering its effectiveness in addressing the issues caused by ethanol while also examining any potential drawbacks or limitations.

Ethanol-free gasoline is better for long-term storage

Ethanol-blended fuel, such as E10 (10% ethanol), is the most common type of fuel found at gas stations and fuel docks. While it has the advantage of reducing emissions and improving combustion stability, it poses challenges for boat owners due to its hygroscopic nature. Over time, ethanol can cause corrosion and deterioration of engine components, fuel lines, and rubber seals. Additionally, it can contribute to clogging in the fuel system and injectors.

On the other hand, non-ethanol gasoline offers better energy density and potentially improved fuel efficiency. It also helps prevent water accumulation, reducing the risk of phase separation and engine issues. However, it is typically more expensive and less readily available. Additionally, it may not be compatible with all marine engines, particularly older models.

When choosing between non-ethanol and regular gasoline for your boat, it's essential to consider your specific needs and priorities. If you prioritise engine longevity and storage stability, non-ethanol gasoline is the better option. However, if convenience and affordability are more important, regular gasoline with ethanol may be sufficient, especially for modern engines.

To make an informed decision, it's recommended to refer to your boat's owner's manual and consult a marine mechanic. They can provide guidance based on your specific engine and boating requirements. Additionally, regular maintenance and the use of fuel stabilisers can help mitigate some of the challenges associated with ethanol-blended fuel.

Ethanol can cause corrosion and deterioration in engine components

Ethanol is a common addition to standard gasoline, often labelled as E10, which contains up to 10% ethanol. Ethanol is derived from corn or other plant materials and is added to fuel to increase its oxygen content, reduce emissions, and improve combustion. However, ethanol in fuel can lead to several issues, primarily corrosion and deterioration in engine components.

Ethanol is hygroscopic, meaning it absorbs water from the atmosphere. This can lead to water accumulation in the fuel system, causing potential engine problems. Water intrusion is a common issue for boats as the engines and fuel systems are not designed to be in the water. When using ethanol-blended fuel, the risk of water intrusion is heightened, and if left unchecked, it can lead to rusting, fuel degradation, and other issues.

The presence of water also facilitates the formation of corrosive byproducts. The oxidation of ethanol creates corrosive substances that can damage engine components over time. These byproducts can cause an etching effect on metal parts, known as white rust. Additionally, ethanol contains trace amounts of acetic acid, which can deteriorate plastics, rubbers, and steel when exposed to humidity. This can lead to the degradation of rubber and plastic parts in engines and fuel lines, resulting in costly repairs.

The corrosive nature of ethanol-blended fuel can also lead to the formation of sludge and the contamination of fuel tanks. The ethanol-water mixture can separate from the gasoline and settle at the bottom of the tank, a phenomenon known as phase separation. This corrosive sludge can clog fuel filters and damage metal components.

Furthermore, ethanol has been linked to microbial contamination in fuel systems. Studies have found that acetobacter bacteria, commonly present in ethanol fuel, produce acetic acid, further contributing to corrosion and the formation of sludge and slime in fuel tanks.

The impact of ethanol on engine components was studied through experiments using different concentrations of ethanol-gasoline blends. The results indicated that higher concentrations of ethanol led to increased corrosion on engine components, particularly the piston surface.

To mitigate the corrosive effects of ethanol, it is recommended to use fuel stabilizers and additives specifically designed to address these issues, such as Biobor EB. Additionally, regular maintenance and inspections of the fuel system are crucial to identify and address any signs of corrosion, debris, or water accumulation.

Non-ethanol gas provides better energy density and improved fuel efficiency

Non-ethanol gas, also known as pure or recreational fuel, offers several advantages over regular gasoline when it comes to fuelling your boat. One of its key benefits is improved energy density. Non-ethanol gasoline has a higher energy content compared to ethanol-blended fuel, resulting in better fuel efficiency. This means that your boat's engine will be able to extract more energy from each unit of non-ethanol fuel, leading to improved performance and a potential increase in mileage.

The higher energy density of non-ethanol gas is particularly noticeable when compared to ethanol-blended fuels like E10, which is the standard gasoline found at most fuel stations. E10 contains up to 10% ethanol, which has a lower energy content than pure gasoline. As a result, boats running on E10 may experience a slight reduction in fuel efficiency. In contrast, non-ethanol gasoline provides improved fuel efficiency, allowing your boat to travel further on the same amount of fuel.

Another advantage of non-ethanol gas is its ability to prevent water accumulation in the fuel system. Ethanol is hygroscopic, meaning it absorbs water. This can lead to phase separation, where ethanol and water separate from the gasoline, causing engine problems and reduced performance. Non-ethanol gasoline, on the other hand, is less prone to phase separation, making it a better choice for maintaining your boat's engine and avoiding issues related to water contamination.

However, it's important to consider the availability and cost of non-ethanol gasoline. It tends to be more expensive and less readily available than regular gasoline. Non-ethanol fuel can usually be found at select fuel stations or specialty suppliers, but its limited availability may require additional effort to source. Additionally, non-ethanol gasoline may not be compatible with all marine engines, particularly older models, which might require adjustments for optimal performance.

Ethanol-blended fuel is more stable in storage

The addition of ethanol as a co-solvent has been shown to prevent the separation of hydrocarbon-methanol blends. Ethanol forms stronger hydrogen bonds with methanol than methanol-water, resulting in a homogeneous and stable mixture. This is particularly effective when the fuel has a high aromatic hydrocarbon composition, as the aromatic hydrocarbon groups have delocalized electrons that exert a more potent attractive force on polar molecules.

However, it is important to note that ethanol is hydrophilic and hygroscopic, meaning it easily dissolves in water and absorbs it from the air. This can lead to water contamination in fuel tanks, causing engine damage and corrosion. Therefore, while ethanol-blended fuel can be more stable in storage, it is important to regularly check for water contamination and remove it if present.

Ethanol is a powerful solvent that can dissolve fuel tanks, filters, and carburetors

Ethanol has the ability to dissolve old gum and varnish deposits from fuel tanks and fuel lines. However, it can also dissolve plastic components, creating harmful deposits. Small-engine manufacturers have warned that ethanol can dissolve plastic, leading to clogged filters and deposits on fuel injectors, fuel pumps, carburetor jets, and other engine parts. This can result in equipment that won't start or performs poorly, potentially causing costly repairs.

Additionally, ethanol's solvent properties can contribute to phase separation in the fuel system. Ethanol absorbs water, and when it reaches its saturation point, it separates from the gasoline, forming two distinct layers in the fuel tank. The lower layer, a mixture of ethanol and water, is highly corrosive and can cause rust and corrosion inside the fuel tank. This corrosive mixture can then pass through fuel filters and damage fuel injectors, leading to further issues.

To mitigate these issues, some people opt for non-oxygenated, ethanol-free gas for their boats. This type of fuel is less commonly available and tends to be more expensive, but it eliminates the problems associated with ethanol, including its solvent properties. Another option is to use fuel additives designed to combat the negative effects of ethanol, such as those that help prevent phase separation and protect engine components from corrosion.

In summary, while ethanol is a powerful solvent that can dissolve fuel tanks, filters, and carburetors, there are ways to manage and prevent these issues. Choosing the right type of fuel and using appropriate fuel additives can help boat owners maintain their engines and fuel systems effectively.

Frequently asked questions