Naturalism In The Open Boat: Man Vs. Nature

Stephen Crane's short story 'The Open Boat' is a classic example of literary naturalism. The story is based on Crane's own experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida in 1897. Crane and three other men were stranded at sea for 30 hours, during which time one of the men drowned.

'The Open Boat' follows four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—who are stranded in a dinghy after their ship sinks overnight. The story explores themes of survival, solidarity, and the conflict between man and nature, with the men battling the elements and their own fatigue in their attempts to reach shore.

The story's naturalist elements include its portrayal of nature as an indifferent, uncaring force, and its exploration of the idea that human characteristics and fates are determined by the environment and external forces beyond human control.

Nature is indifferent to man

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", nature is indifferent to man's fate. The story is based on Crane's own experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida in 1897. He and three other men were stranded at sea for 30 hours, during which time they had to navigate their way to shore in a small boat. One of the men, an oiler, drowned after the boat overturned.

Crane's story is considered an exemplary work of literary naturalism, exploring themes such as survival, solidarity, and the conflict between man and nature. The four men in the boat—the correspondent, the captain, the cook, and the oiler—represent different classes of men and human qualities. They are stranded in a small dinghy after their ship sinks, and the story focuses on their constant battle between their environment and their survival. The sea, which is beyond their control, becomes a symbol of nature's indifference. Despite their efforts to navigate and keep the boat afloat, their fate is ultimately determined by the indifferent forces of nature.

Throughout the story, the men's moods fluctuate between anger at their desperate situation and a growing empathy for one another. They become fatigued and bicker with one another, but they also take turns rowing and bailing water to keep the boat afloat. Their hope is tempered by the realisation of the danger of trying to reach the lighthouse on the horizon. The correspondent, who is based on Crane himself, regularly refers to the sea with feminine pronouns, pitting the four men against an intangible, yet effeminate threat.

As the story progresses, the reality of nature's lack of concern for the men becomes increasingly clear. While nature is as randomly helpful as it is hurtful, providing favourable winds or calm nights, it is also a harsh punisher. The very thing that has put the men in harm's way—the sea—is also what ultimately saves them. However, the same freak wave that plows the correspondent to shore may also be responsible for killing the oiler, the strongest swimmer. This turn of events demonstrates that nature acts without any motivation that can be understood in human terms. It is as much a benefactor as it is a punisher, and its actions are random and indifferent.

Crane's portrayal of nature as indifferent is strengthened by the unaltered activity of the gulls, clouds, and tides, which illustrates that nature does not behave any differently in light of the men's struggle to survive. The men are forced to rely on one another for survival, creating a microcosm of mankind in the dinghy. They derive meaning from their fellowship, which becomes their best defence against the chaos of nature. Despite their efforts to navigate and keep the boat afloat, their fate is ultimately determined by the indifferent forces of nature.

Man is insignificant in the universe

"The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane is a naturalist story that reflects on the insignificance of man in the universe. The story revolves around four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—stranded in a dinghy after their ship sinks. Through their battle for survival against the unforgiving sea, Crane explores themes of human endurance, the indifference of nature, and the realisation of one's insignificance in the universe.

The men in the dinghy represent a microcosm of society, with their diverse personalities and reactions to their dire situation. The oiler, for instance, embodies the hardworking nature of the working class, while the correspondent, with his self-centred and idealistic tendencies, symbolises the higher class. Despite their differences, the men are united by their shared struggle and develop a sense of camaraderie as they face an indifferent universe together.

Crane's depiction of nature, particularly the sea, is a key element in conveying man's insignificance. The sea is described as an unforgiving, relentless force that continues on "wave after wave of relentless fatigue", indifferent to the men's plight. The gulls, clouds, and tides continue on unchanged, highlighting that "nature does not behave any differently in light of the men's struggle to survive". The sea becomes a symbol of the universe at large—an immense, powerful force that man cannot control or influence.

As the men grapple with their mortality and the seeming randomness of their fate, they question the role of fate and the existence of a higher power. They realise that their lives and deaths may ultimately have no greater meaning, and that the universe is indifferent to their existence. This realisation brings about a sense of despair and loneliness, as captured in the correspondent's internal monologue:

> "If I am going to be drowned—if I am going to be drowned—if I am going to be drowned, why, in the name of the seven mad gods who rule the sea, was I allowed to come thus far and contemplate sand and trees? Was I brought here merely to have my nose dragged away as I was about to nibble the sacred cheese of life? It is preposterous."

The story's ending further underscores the theme of man's insignificance. The men, after enduring countless hardships, finally reach the shore, only to find that the oiler, the strongest among them, has drowned. This twist of fate highlights the randomness and unpredictability of the universe, reinforcing the idea that man has little control over his destiny.

In "The Open Boat", Crane masterfully captures the sense of loneliness and insignificance that comes from the understanding that one is alone in a vast, indifferent universe. Through the men's battle for survival, he explores the human condition, the struggle between man and nature, and the realisation that, in the grand scheme of things, man is but a small player in a universe that continues on, unconcerned.

Nature is all-powerful

The story revolves around four shipwrecked men: the captain, the cook, the correspondent, and the oiler. Nature is the main character because each of the four men tries hard not to anger it or disturb it. They plead with the sea to let them pass safely. The men are at the mercy of nature's indifference to their fate. The sea is portrayed as a powerful, uncaring force, continuing on in wave after wave of relentless fatigue, indifferent to the men's struggle to survive.

The men are forced to rely on each other for survival, banding together to create a microcosm of mankind, a society that is their best defence against the chaos of nature. The story conveys a feeling of loneliness that comes from man's understanding of his insignificance in the universe and the workings of nature. The men are shut out of the realm of cosmic importance, yet they construct something meaningful to them through their solidarity.

The sea is described in human-like terms, snarling, hissing, and bucking like a bronco. But this is simply a projection of the men's perception of the sea, which is in reality indifferent to their struggle. The sea does not care about their suffering. It is as randomly helpful as it is hurtful, destroying the notion of nature as an entirely hostile force. Nature is as much a harsh punisher as it is a benefactor, acting not out of any motivation that can be understood in human terms, but simply as itself.

The men are puppets to the ocean and the winds, left to the randomness of external forces beyond their control. Nature is an all-powerful entity, acting of its own accord, and those who act within it are subject to its randomness and power.

The sea is uncaring

The sea is a powerful force, and in Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat", it is a central character. The sea is an indifferent force, acting with neither malice nor benevolence. It is a force of nature, uncaring and unyielding, and it is this aspect of nature that the men must battle against.

The men in the dinghy are at the mercy of the sea, and their fate is not in their hands but in the hands of nature. The sea does not care if they live or die. It is a "giant, standing with its back to the plight of the ants", and the men are like "ants" in comparison to this force of nature. The sea is a bronco, bucking and snarling, and the men are tossed about by its waves.

The sea is unforgiving and relentless. Wave after wave of "relentless fatigue" washes over the men, and they are helpless to do anything but endure. The sea is a "nervously anxious" force, and the men are but playthings in its path. The men are "impressed with the unconcern of the universe", and this indifference is a key theme in the story. The universe is not a kind or religious place, and man is alone, with no divine intervention to save him.

The sea is a powerful symbol of naturalism, and it is a force that the men cannot overcome. They are "puppets to the ocean and the winds", and their dinghy is at the mercy of the waves. Nature is an "indifferent force", and the sea does not care about the suffering of the men. It is a deterministic universe, and the men are subject to its randomness and power.

The sea is an ever-present threat, and the men are in a constant state of peril. They are "helpless in the face of nature", and their "lives could be lost at any moment". The sea is an intangible, yet effeminate, threat, and the men are pitted against it in a battle for survival.

The sea is an indifferent force, and it does not discriminate. The strongest swimmer, the oiler, drowns, and nature shows no preference for the men. The sea is a random force, and the men are subject to its whims. It is a harsh punisher, and the men are at its mercy.

Nature is deterministic

In Stephen Crane's short story, "The Open Boat", the deterministic nature of the universe is a central theme. The story revolves around four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—stranded in a dinghy after their ship sinks. Throughout their struggle for survival, the men grapple with the indifference and unpredictability of nature, which seems to control their fate.

The deterministic nature of the universe, as portrayed in "The Open Boat", can be examined through three lenses: the powerlessness of humans, the indifference of nature, and the role of natural metaphors.

Human Powerlessness

The four men in "The Open Boat" are at the mercy of the unforgiving sea, highlighting their lack of control over their destinies. They are buffeted by waves, threatened by sharks, and exhausted by the relentless environment. Despite their efforts to navigate and survive, they are ultimately powerless against the forces of nature. This power dynamic underscores the deterministic view that human actions are governed by external forces beyond their understanding or control.

Indifference of Nature

Nature, personified as a female entity, is depicted as indifferent, uncaring, and relentless in the story. The sea does not discriminate between the strong and the weak, as evidenced by the death of the physically strongest oiler. The men's pleas for mercy go unanswered, and the sea continues to batter them with wave after wave. Nature's indifference further emphasizes the deterministic philosophy, suggesting that the universe is unconcerned with individual human struggles and that human fate is predetermined by forces beyond their control.

Natural Metaphors

Crane's use of metaphors and similes involving animals and natural elements serves to broaden the scope of the tale. He compares the waves to rocks, a wild horse, and a snarling land animal, personifying the sea as a hostile force. The seagulls are likened to prairie chickens, unaffected by the turmoil below. These natural metaphors highlight the insignificance of human struggles in the grand scheme of nature, reinforcing the deterministic view that human existence is subject to the whims of a larger, indifferent universe.

In "The Open Boat", Stephen Crane presents a deterministic view of nature, where human actions and destinies are governed by forces beyond their control. The powerlessness of the men against the sea, the indifference of nature, and the use of natural metaphors all contribute to this theme. Through their harrowing journey, the characters come to terms with the harsh reality of a universe that does not cater to their desires or pleadings, shaping their understanding of their place in the world.

Frequently asked questions