Helena Frye
There is some debate over whether the Ranger's favoured terrain abilities work on a boat. Some argue that being on a boat should count as aquatic terrain because of the unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, and other terrain matters characteristic of aquatic terrain. Others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain because the Ranger's Favoured Terrain list specifies water terrain as above and below the water. Ultimately, it is up to the Dungeon Master to decide whether the boat counts as aquatic terrain and whether the Ranger's favoured terrain abilities apply.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Does favoured terrain aquatic work on a boat? | It depends on the game and the ruling of the DM. |
| Ranger's favoured terrain list | Water terrain is specified as above and below the water. |
| Ranger's favoured terrain abilities | Some are virtually unusable while actively treading water. |
| Boat terrain | Some consider the boat itself to be aquatic terrain. |
| Boat terrain | Some consider the boat to be the terrain of the place it is in, e.g. urban terrain if it is in a city. |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
The boat is in a city, so it counts as urban
There is some debate about whether being on a boat counts as being in aquatic terrain. Some people argue that being on a boat should count as aquatic terrain, as it involves unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, navigation by stars, and extra sensitivity to wind. Others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain, as the water terrain is specified as above and below the water, and being on a boat doesn't necessarily mean you're in the water.
However, the question of whether favoured terrain aquatic works on a boat is separate from the question of whether the boat itself is considered aquatic terrain. In the case of a boat docked in a city, the boat would be considered urban terrain, as that is the terrain of the surrounding area. This is similar to how a ranger with favoured terrain of plains would still have their bonuses while travelling across the plains in a wagon.
Therefore, if a character with favoured terrain aquatic were on a boat in a city, they would not have the benefits of their favoured terrain, as the boat would be considered urban terrain.
Grasshopper Boat Ownership: Mystery Unveiled
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The boat is in the water, so it counts as aquatic
There is some debate as to whether a boat counts as aquatic terrain. Some people argue that being on a boat should count as aquatic terrain because it involves unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, navigation by stars, and extra sensitivity to wind. Additionally, a huge number of ranger favoured terrain abilities are virtually unusable while actively treading water, making this super impractical.
Others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain because the water terrain is specified as above and below the water. This raises the question of whether "above water" counts as aquatic terrain, and if so, whether one has to be literally walking on water for that to apply.
Ultimately, it seems that the ruling on this matter may depend on the specific campaign and the DM's interpretation. In one example, a DM ruled that a docked boat was in a city and therefore counted as urban terrain.
It's worth noting that even if the boat itself is not considered aquatic terrain, many of the skills associated with aquatic terrain, such as initiative, Knowledge (geography), Perception, Stealth, and Survival, can still be beneficial to an ocean expert on a ship. For example, an ocean expert would know what signs to look for on the water to spot enemies, how to shield their eyes or filter out scents, and how camouflage works on the water.
Blackish and Fresh Off the Boat: Similar but Different Paths
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The boat is not in the water, so it doesn't count as aquatic
The question of whether a boat counts as aquatic terrain is a matter of debate. Some people argue that a boat should count as aquatic terrain because it involves unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, navigation by stars, and extra sensitivity to wind. However, others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain because the Ranger's Favoured Terrain list specifies water terrain as above and below the water.
One interpretation is that the boat itself is the terrain, and therefore, if the boat is in the water, it counts as aquatic. This is similar to the argument that a wagon travelling across plains would still count as plains terrain. Additionally, many of a ranger's favoured terrain abilities are usable on a boat, such as initiative checks, Knowledge (geography), Perception, Stealth, and Survival skill checks.
However, it is important to note that the specific rules and interpretations may vary depending on the game or campaign being played. The Dungeon Master (DM) or Game Master (GM) may have the final ruling on whether a boat counts as aquatic terrain in a particular game or campaign.
Boat Launching at Pactola: Open for Business?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The boat is moving around on the waves, so it counts as aquatic
There is some debate as to whether a boat counts as aquatic terrain. Some people argue that a boat should count as aquatic terrain because it involves unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, navigation by stars, extra sensitivity to wind, and other terrain matters characteristic of aquatic terrain. Additionally, a boat is in the water and moving around on the waves, so it could be considered part of the aquatic terrain.
However, others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain because the Ranger's Favored Terrain list specifies water terrain as above and below the water, and a boat is not technically under the water.
Ultimately, it is up to the DM to rule on whether a boat counts as aquatic terrain in a specific campaign. In one example, a DM ruled that a docked boat was in a city and therefore counted as urban terrain.
Fixing Aluminum Boat Dents: DIY Guide and Tips
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The boat is docked, so it doesn't count as aquatic
There is some debate as to whether a boat counts as aquatic terrain. Some people argue that being on a boat should count as aquatic terrain because it involves unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, navigation by stars, and extra sensitivity to wind. Others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain because the Ranger's Favoured Terrain list specifies water terrain as above and below the water, and a boat is neither of these.
In the case of a docked boat, it could be argued that the boat is part of the terrain that it is docked in. For example, if a boat is docked in a city, it could be considered urban terrain. Therefore, if a boat is docked, it does not count as aquatic terrain.
Miami Boat Owners: Get Custom Name Decals Here
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
There is some debate about this. Some people argue that being on a boat should count as aquatic terrain because it involves unusual movement underfoot, spray in the air, navigation by stars, and extra sensitivity to wind. Others argue that boats don't count as aquatic terrain because the Ranger's Favoured Terrain list specifies water terrain as above and below the water.
In this case, the boat would count as urban terrain.
Then the boat would count as aquatic terrain because it is in the water.
No, a huge number of a ranger's favoured terrain abilities are virtually unusable while actively treading water.
