Steel Vs Aluminum: Which Fuel Tank Is Superior For Boats?

When it comes to choosing a fuel tank for your boat, there are several factors to consider, including the type of material used. While stainless steel and aluminium are both viable options, each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages that should be carefully weighed before making a decision. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of each material to help you make an informed choice for your unique needs.

Plastic tanks are more durable and cheaper than aluminium

When it comes to choosing the right fuel tank for your boat, there are several factors to consider, including cost, durability, and compatibility with gasoline or diesel fuel. While aluminium fuel tanks have their advantages, plastic tanks offer a more durable and cost-effective solution.

One of the most significant benefits of plastic tanks is their durability. Plastic tanks, if properly manufactured, will outlast aluminium marine tanks. They are made from high-density polyethylene (HDPE) resin, which is incredibly durable and reliable for gasoline fuel. Plastic tanks are also non-metallic composites, which means they won't introduce galvanic action to other components on your boat. Additionally, polyethylene fuel tanks have stronger seams than aluminium, making them more resistant to fractures.

Another advantage of plastic tanks is their cost-effectiveness. Plastic marine fuel tanks are less expensive than aluminium ones. This is especially beneficial if you need a custom-made tank, as aluminium customization can be costly. Plastic tanks also eliminate the risk of corrosion, which is a common issue with aluminium tanks. Aluminium tanks are susceptible to crevice corrosion, especially when exposed to moisture or saltwater.

It's important to note that plastic tanks have some limitations. They may not have baffles inside to limit the swashing of fuel, which can be a concern for larger tanks. Additionally, the selection of plastic tanks may be limited, especially for custom or less popular boat designs. However, plastic tank technology has improved, and modern tanks meet USCG fire resistance requirements and have significantly reduced vapour release.

In conclusion, plastic tanks offer a more durable and cost-effective solution for boat fuel tanks compared to aluminium. They are corrosion-resistant, have stronger seams, and are less expensive. While plastic tanks may have some limitations regarding baffles and customization, they are a reliable choice for standard gasoline-powered boats.

Aluminium tanks are custom-made and have baffles to stabilise fuel

Aluminium fuel tanks are custom-made, allowing boat owners to match their boat's design and take advantage of extra space to allow for more fuel capacity. They also come with baffles to stabilise fuel and prevent it from sloshing around excessively. This is particularly important for large tanks, as baffles can reduce sloshing and the movement of the boat.

Aluminium tanks are also said to be more durable than plastic tanks, with some claiming that a high-quality aluminium tank can outlast the boat itself. While plastic tanks are also durable and resistant to corrosion, they are more prone to fuel vapours and may not last as long as aluminium tanks.

Aluminium tanks are a popular choice for boat owners due to their customisability, durability, and fuel stabilisation features. However, it is important to note that they require proper maintenance and airflow to prevent corrosion, especially with the introduction of ethanol fuel, which can attract water and cause galvanic reactions.

Overall, aluminium tanks offer a combination of customisation, durability, and fuel stabilisation that makes them a popular choice for boat owners.

Plastic tanks are not affected by ethanol

When it comes to choosing the right fuel tank for your boat, there are several factors to consider, including the type of boat, fuel, and personal preference. While stainless steel and aluminum are common choices, plastic tanks have emerged as a popular alternative, offering unique benefits that cater specifically to ethanol fuel.

Plastic tanks, particularly those made from polyethylene, possess distinct advantages over their metal counterparts when it comes to storing ethanol fuel. One of the most crucial benefits is their resistance to corrosion. Unlike metal tanks that can be susceptible to corrosion over time, plastic tanks made from polyethylene are inherently corrosion-resistant. This attribute ensures that your tank remains intact and your fuel supply secure, even in harsh marine environments.

Another critical factor to consider is the durability of plastic tanks. Properly manufactured plastic tanks can outlast aluminum marine tanks. The durability of plastic tanks stems from their ability to withstand the negative effects of ethanol. Ethanol has a reputation for attracting water, which can lead to corrosion in metal tanks. However, plastic tanks are unaffected by this issue, providing a more reliable and long-lasting solution for boat owners.

Additionally, plastic tanks offer a more cost-effective solution. They are often more affordable than aluminum tanks, making them a budget-friendly option for boat owners. Furthermore, plastic tanks are incredibly durable and reliable for gasoline, according to industry experts. This reliability stems from their ability to withstand the challenges posed by ethanol, including its tendency to attract water.

One of the most significant advantages of plastic tanks is their non-metallic composition. This feature ensures that they do not introduce galvanic action to other components on your boat. Galvanic action, or the creation of a voltage difference between dissimilar metals when in contact with an electrolyte, can lead to corrosion and damage. By opting for plastic tanks, you eliminate this concern and protect your boat from potential issues arising from galvanic reactions.

Lastly, plastic tanks, specifically those made from polyethylene, possess stronger seams than aluminum. While plastic may not be stronger than aluminum in terms of tensile strength, the seams of polyethylene tanks are more robust and less prone to failure. This advantage becomes particularly important when considering the constant pressure and jarring that boat fuel tanks endure during their lifetime.

In conclusion, plastic tanks offer a compelling option for boat owners, especially when considering the unique challenges posed by ethanol fuel. Their corrosion resistance, durability, cost-effectiveness, non-metallic composition, and strong seams make them a reliable and attractive choice. However, it is essential to consider all factors, including personal preferences, to make an informed decision when choosing the right fuel tank for your boat.

Aluminium tanks are more prone to galvanic reactions

Due to ethanol's action of attracting water, aluminium marine fuel tanks can and most often do create galvanic reactions throughout your boat. Zinc can be placed on the tank for exterior protection, but this does no good for the interior, thus leading to problems extending beyond just your tank. Corrosion will also attack the welded seams from the inside out.

Aluminium does not take well to alloys that are not of the same. A simple loose bolt, screw, nut, or any other metal object that were to fall on the tank and continue contact would eventually corrode that area. Loose washers or other items seem to always find their way to the tank area.

In summary, aluminium tanks are more prone to galvanic reactions due to the combination of ethanol fuel, water attraction, a lack of protective coating, and the vulnerability of aluminium alloys to corrosion when in contact with other metals.

Aluminium tanks are more susceptible to corrosion

Aluminium tanks are also more prone to corrosion if they are scratched, as the natural oxide coating that protects the metal is removed. Additionally, aluminium does not respond well to contact with alloys that are not the same, so if a loose bolt, screw, nut, or any other metal object falls on the tank and remains in contact, it will eventually corrode that area.

Aluminium tanks are also affected by the introduction of ethanol in fuel, as ethanol attracts water, which can lead to corrosion. This can also create galvanic reactions throughout the boat, causing issues beyond just the fuel tank.

While aluminium tanks can last for many years, studies show that they typically begin to weaken and need to be replaced after about 10 years. Proper maintenance, such as keeping the tank dry and ensuring good airflow, can help extend the life of an aluminium tank.

Frequently asked questions