The Benefits Of Twin Engines On Boats

There are several reasons why boats have two engines. Firstly, having two engines increases the boat's power output and provides a quicker acceleration than a single engine. Secondly, in the case of one engine breaking down, the other can serve as a backup to get the boat back home safely. This is especially useful when boating in deep waters or rough weather conditions. Thirdly, for activities like fishing, having two engines allows for a powerful motor to quickly reach the fishing spot, and then a quieter, smaller engine can be used to avoid scaring away the fish. Lastly, two engines provide better maneuverability, stability, and resale value for the boat.

Safety: Two engines provide a backup in case one fails, but only if they have separate fuel systems

Safety is a key consideration for boats with two engines. The idea is that if one engine malfunctions or fails to start, the other can be used to safely return to shore or port. However, this is only true if the engines have separate fuel systems. If both engines draw fuel from the same tank, a problem with the fuel supply will stop both engines.

Having two engines can provide peace of mind, especially when navigating offshore or in open seas, far from the coast. However, it's important to note that engine reliability has improved significantly over the years, and mechanical issues are rare. Most problems with outboard engines are fuel-related, affecting 90% of engines. Therefore, having separate fuel systems for each engine is crucial to ensuring one engine can still function if the other encounters fuel issues.

To achieve true redundancy and safety benefits, it's recommended to have two separate fuel tanks with independent lines and filters. This way, if there is an issue with one fuel supply, the other engine can continue operating without risk of failure. It's also advisable to keep one of the tanks filled with gasoline from a trusted source. In the event of bad fuel or water contamination in one tank, the boat can switch to the other tank and continue its journey.

By implementing these measures, boaters can enhance their safety and mitigate the risks associated with engine failure.

Speed: Two engines can provide more horsepower and faster acceleration, but may also increase drag

Speed: The Benefits of Two Engines

Two engines on a boat can provide several benefits in terms of speed, but there are also some potential drawbacks. Firstly, let's look at the advantages.

More Horsepower

Two engines can provide more horsepower, which generally results in faster acceleration and a higher top speed. This is because each additional engine adds more power, leading to a significant increase in overall speed. For example, a twin-engine setup with two 150-horsepower motors can achieve an acceleration of 30 mph in just 5.5 seconds, while a single 250-horsepower motor takes approximately 8 seconds to reach the same speed.

Improved Maneuverability

Twin-engine boats tend to have better low-speed maneuverability, especially in tight spaces or crowded marinas. They can move around their center without the need for frequent forward and reverse shifts, which is advantageous when dealing with strong winds or currents. Additionally, twin-engine setups provide greater control and stability at high speeds, minimizing the need for continuous corrections.

Safety Redundancy

While not directly related to speed, it is worth mentioning that having two engines adds a layer of safety. In the unlikely event of a breakdown, the second engine can serve as a backup to get you back to the harbor. However, it is important to ensure that the two engines have independent fuel systems, as fuel-related issues can affect both engines if they draw fuel from the same tank.

Potential Drawback: Increased Drag

Now, let's discuss the potential drawback of having two engines in terms of speed.

Hydrodynamic Drag

Twin-engine setups have two gearboxes that create more hydrodynamic drag in the water. This increased drag can lead to reduced speed and higher fuel consumption compared to a single-engine setup with the same horsepower. Therefore, it is crucial to ensure that the combined horsepower of the two engines is at least 30% higher than a single engine to achieve better performance.

In summary, while two engines on a boat can provide more horsepower and faster acceleration, it is important to consider the potential increase in hydrodynamic drag. To maximize the benefits of a twin-engine setup, ensure that the combined horsepower is significantly higher than a single engine, and consider having independent fuel systems for added safety and reliability.

Manoeuvrability: Two engines make it easier to rotate the boat in place and move in tight quarters

When it comes to boating, manoeuvrability is a crucial factor, especially when navigating through tight spaces or crowded marinas. This is where the advantage of having two engines comes into play.

With two engines, a boat can rotate in place and move with greater ease in confined areas. This is achieved by putting one motor forward and the other backward, allowing the boat to turn on its centre point without the need for frequent forward and reverse shifts, which is common in single-engine boats. This enhanced manoeuvrability is particularly useful when dealing with strong winds or currents, as it provides better control and precision in the boat's movement.

The benefits of two engines are further highlighted when docking or navigating in tight quarters. The twin-engine setup enables the boat to "walk" sideways, making it simpler to sidle up to a dock or manoeuvre in narrow spaces. Additionally, some twin-engine configurations offer the option of adding a joystick docking control system, providing even greater precision and ease of use when docking or moving at low speeds.

The improved manoeuvrability of twin-engine boats is also evident in their ability to handle strong tidal currents and rough weather conditions. The additional power and control provided by two engines make it easier to navigate through challenging situations and quickly get to safety if needed.

It is worth noting that while two engines offer improved manoeuvrability, it is important to ensure that they are not connected to the same fuel tank. In the event of a fuel-related issue, having separate fuel supplies for each engine ensures that both engines won't be affected simultaneously, providing an added layer of reliability and safety.

Cost: Two engines can more than double the cost of power and maintenance

The cost of two engines can more than double the cost of power and maintenance. The rigging, which includes controls, wiring harnesses, cables, instrumentation, propping, and labour, is nearly twice as expensive for two engines compared to a single engine. Maintenance costs are also doubled. The purchase price of a second engine, as well as the extra equipment and working hours required for a twin-engine boat, should also be considered. This includes the cost of an additional battery, filters, spare propellers, electrical installations, and fuel systems.

The higher cost of two engines is further justified by the increased horsepower they provide. A hull fitted with two engines can have significantly more horsepower than a hull with a single engine. For example, a hull with two 150-horsepower engines will have a total of 300 horsepower, compared to a single engine hull with only 150 horsepower. This increased horsepower comes at a cost, as the additional engines and equipment required can be expensive.

The weight and drag of two engines also impact the overall cost and performance of the boat. Two smaller engines often weigh more than a single large engine, which can adversely affect the top speed and fuel efficiency of the boat. Additionally, the increased surface area and drag of two engines can reduce the speed and efficiency of the boat. While modern engines are lighter and more compact than their predecessors, the weight and drag of two engines can still impact the overall cost and performance.

The initial cost of purchasing and installing two engines, as well as the ongoing maintenance and operating costs, should be carefully considered when deciding between a single or twin-engine configuration. The higher cost of two engines may be justified in certain situations, such as when higher horsepower, improved manoeuvrability, or added redundancy is required. However, in other cases, a single engine may be a more cost-effective and efficient option.

Weight: Two smaller engines often weigh more than one large engine, which can impact speed

Weight is a significant factor when considering a single or twin-engine setup for a boat. Two smaller engines often weigh more than a single large engine, which can impact speed. For example, a Yamaha F250 outboard engine weighs 619 pounds, while a pair of Yamaha F115s weigh a combined 772 pounds (386 pounds each). This extra weight can adversely affect the top speed of the boat.

In a test of the Key West 244CC, a single F250 engine achieved a top speed of 45.2 mph, while twin F115s reached 43 mph. The lower speed of the twin-engine setup can be attributed to both the extra weight and their slightly lower overall horsepower. However, it's important to note that in some cases, a twin-engine setup can be faster. When comparing a Yamaha F300 to a pair of Yamaha F150s, the twin setup achieved a higher speed of 53.6 mph versus 49.5 mph for the single engine.

The weight difference between single and twin-engine setups becomes more pronounced when considering the additional equipment required for multiple engines. The cost of rigging, including controls, wiring harnesses, cables, instrumentation, and labour, is nearly doubled for twin engines compared to a single engine. This increased weight and complexity can impact not only speed but also fuel efficiency and maintenance requirements.

While modern engines are lighter and more compact than their predecessors, the weight difference between a single large engine and two smaller engines remains a critical consideration when deciding between the two setups. The added weight of twin engines can affect not only speed but also fuel efficiency, handling, and overall performance of the boat.

Frequently asked questions