The Dry Cigars' Mystery In The Open Boat

In Stephen Crane's short story, 'The Open Boat', the cigars symbolise the random nature of fate. The correspondent finds eight cigars in his pocket, four of which are dry and four of which are wet. This is significant because there are four men in the boat, and the cigars seem to foreshadow the outcome of the men—will they be dry or drenched? Will they survive or drown? The cigars also symbolise the fluctuation between optimism and pessimism, mirroring the men's feelings as they cycle through exhaustion, joy, anger, hope, and tenacity. The cigars are also seen as a symbol of hope for spiritual salvation, and ultimately, the loss of that salvation.

The cigars symbolise the random nature of fate

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat," the cigars symbolise the random nature of fate. The story's narrator, the correspondent, discovers eight cigars in his coat pocket—four soaked and four dry—after the men spot a lighthouse. The cigars are a symbol of the random and inexplicable nature of fate, mirroring the uncertainty of the men's fate as they cycle through emotions of exhaustion, joy, anger, and hopefulness.

The cigars also symbolise the men's fluctuating optimism and pessimism. Initially, the men optimistically interpret the dry cigars as a sign of their ability to remain untouched by the demoralising forces of nature. However, by the story's end, their optimism fades, and the wet cigars better reflect their spirits.

The cigars are also symbolic of the men's closeness and celebration of their anticipated rescue. The act of smoking the cigars together reinforces their unity and camaraderie in the face of adversity.

Furthermore, the cigars add to the suspense surrounding the men's fate. The contrast between the dry and wet cigars mirrors the uncertainty of whether the men will survive or drown, creating tension and leaving the outcome open until the end.

The cigars, in combination with other symbols in the story, such as the boat and the soldier, highlight the overarching theme of the unpredictability of fate and the powerlessness of humans in the face of nature's whims.

The dry cigars represent hope for rescue

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat," the correspondent discovers eight cigars in his pocket, four of which are dry and four of which are soaked with seawater. This discovery occurs as the men in the boat approach a lighthouse, and their hope of rescue grows. The dry cigars, therefore, represent optimism and hope for rescue.

The cigars are a symbol of the random and inexplicable nature of fate. The fact that the correspondent only discovers the cigars at this point in the story, and that there is one dry cigar for each man, suggests that fate is arbitrary and resists simple explanation. The dry cigars can be seen as a sign of good fortune, a symbol of the men's optimism, and a source of celebration and camaraderie as they smoke together.

The cigars also symbolise the fluctuating nature of the men's outlook throughout the story. As they cycle through emotions of exhaustion, joy, anger, and hope, the dry cigars represent the optimism that they feel at this particular moment in the story. The cigars are a source of comfort and a symbol of spiritual salvation, contrasting with the wet cigars, which represent the physical and spiritual demoralisation of the men as they battle the forces of nature.

The dry cigars, therefore, represent a turning point in the story, where the men's spirits are lifted by the prospect of rescue. However, this optimism is short-lived, and the men ultimately feel misery rather than triumph. The dry cigars symbolise a brief respite from despair, a moment of hope and camaraderie that is soon replaced by the harsh realities of their situation.

The wet cigars symbolise the men's despair

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", the four wet cigars found by the correspondent symbolise the despair and pessimism felt by the men as they struggle to survive at sea. Initially, the cigars—half of which are dry—seem to symbolise hope and the possibility of rescue, with one cigar for each man. However, this optimism is short-lived, and the men soon feel "misery, not triumph".

The wet cigars can be seen as a reflection of the men's spirits, which are weighed down by the heavy, demoralising forces of nature. The cigars, like the men, are "broken and useless", having been soaked by the sea. This interpretation is reinforced by the fact that the correspondent discovers the cigars in his pocket at the same time that the men are feeling increasingly optimistic about their chances of rescue. The cigars symbolise the underlying reality of their desperate situation, which their temporary optimism cannot change.

The cigars also symbolise the random and inexplicable nature of fate. The correspondent is suddenly aware of the cigars, without knowing how they ended up in his pocket or why four of them are completely dry. This mirrors the unpredictable nature of the sea and the uncertainty of the men's fate.

The cigars serve as a complex symbol, reflecting both the optimism and despair felt by the men as their outlook fluctuates. Ultimately, the wet cigars symbolise the men's despair and the tragic nature of their struggle for survival.

The cigars are a symbol of spiritual salvation

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat," the cigars are indeed a symbol of spiritual salvation. The story's narrator, the correspondent, discovers eight cigars in his coat pocket, four of which are soaked with seawater, while the other four are miraculously untouched. This discovery occurs at a pivotal moment in the story, as the men in the boat are approaching a lighthouse and their hope of rescue is growing.

The cigars can be seen as a symbol of optimism and spiritual salvation in several ways. Firstly, the number of cigars is significant. There are four dry cigars, coincidentally leaving one for each of the four men in the boat. This equal distribution suggests a sense of fairness and camaraderie among the men, who have been working together to survive. Secondly, the dry cigars represent resilience and perseverance in the face of adversity. Despite being soaked by the sea, these cigars remain untouched and usable, much like the men themselves, who have endured the harsh conditions of their journey.

The cigars also symbolise the random and inexplicable nature of fate. The correspondent's sudden discovery of the cigars, without any prior knowledge of their existence, mirrors the unpredictable nature of life and the sea. The men's optimism and hope fluctuate throughout the story, and the cigars reflect this duality. The dry cigars represent the men's resilience and their belief in their ability to survive, while the wet cigars symbolise the demoralising forces of nature that threaten to break them.

The act of smoking the cigars together further reinforces the symbolism of spiritual salvation. As the men puff on the cigars, they feel a sense of closeness and camaraderie, celebrating their impending rescue. The cigars provide a moment of comfort and normalcy in the midst of their harrowing journey. However, this sense of optimism is short-lived, as the men's feelings of triumph and salvation give way to misery and despair by the end of the story.

Overall, the cigars serve as a complex symbol of hope, resilience, and the ultimate loss of salvation. They reflect the men's fluctuating emotions and their struggle to maintain optimism in the face of nature's indifferent whims.

The cigars foreshadow the outcome for the men

In Stephen Crane's short story, "The Open Boat," the cigars that the correspondent finds in his pocket serve as a complex symbol of hope and impending rescue, as well as the ultimate loss of that hope. The cigars also foreshadow the outcome for the men, with four dry cigars and four wet cigars adding to the suspense surrounding their fate. Will they survive, like the dry cigars, or will they be left drenched and broken, like the wet ones?

The cigars symbolise the random and inexplicable nature of fate. The correspondent, who represents the author, Crane, stumbles upon eight cigars in his pocket, four of which are miraculously dry despite their exposure to the elements. This discovery coincides with the men's growing optimism as they approach the lighthouse and watch the land emerge from the sea. The cigars symbolise their feelings of hope and deliverance, which grow in proportion to the expanding vision of land.

However, the cigars also foreshadow the men's ultimate loss of hope and the tragedy of their spirits. Despite their initial optimism, the men's outlook fluctuates throughout the story, cycling through emotions of exhaustion, joy, anger, and tenacity. The wet cigars symbolise the physical and spiritual soaking the men experience due to the heavy, demoralising forces of nature. By the end of the story, the men's optimism is gone, and they feel misery rather than triumph.

The cigars, therefore, serve as a dual symbol, reflecting both the hope and despair experienced by the men. The dry cigars represent the possibility of rescue and survival, while the wet cigars foreshadow the men's ultimate struggle against the indifferent and destructive power of nature. The cigars symbolise the random nature of fate, which can turn from optimism to despair in an instant, leaving the men to cling to their fragile boat amidst the uncertainties of the open sea.

Frequently asked questions