Shocking Shark Dragging Incident: What Species Was It?

A viral video from 2017 sparked outrage among the public and shark enthusiasts alike. The video depicted a shark being violently dragged behind a speedboat in Florida, with a group of men laughing and gesturing at the struggling animal. This incident prompted an investigation by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission and led to charges of animal cruelty against the individuals involved. The shark species was not initially identified, but the public's response was clear: this type of behaviour towards wildlife is unacceptable.

The identities of the men involved

The video, which went viral, was initially sent to Mark "The Shark" Quartiano, a well-known deep-sea fisherman and self-proclaimed shark hunter in the Miami area, by Wenzel. Quartiano posted the video to his Instagram account, expressing his outrage and disapproval of the men's actions. He also received still photos of the bloodied remains of the shark, which was later dragged into the boat. Quartiano's followers quickly identified one of the participants as someone who was known for posting images of himself with dead fish.

Online commenters singled out one of the men as a Manatee County angler with a history of posting disturbing pictures of himself handling wildlife, including birds and fish. This individual had previously drawn protests for his handling of wildlife and had a history of troubling social media posts.

The FWC and prosecutors from the Hillsborough County State Attorney's Office worked together to investigate the incident and bring charges against the individuals involved. They conducted extensive research into the suspects' social media activity and consulted with shark experts to identify any violations that occurred.

The charges and penalties

In 2017, a viral video surfaced, showing three Florida men, Michael Wenzel, 21, Spencer Heintz, 23, and Robert Lee Benac, 28, violently dragging a shark behind their speeding boat. The shark was caught on a fishing line or rope by its tail fin and was thrust into the air several times as the boat picked up speed. The video, which was initially sent to South Florida shark hunter Mark "The Shark" Quartiano, caused widespread outrage and led to charges being filed against the three men.

Charges:

• All three men were charged with two felony counts of aggravated animal cruelty.
• Wenzel and Benac faced an additional misdemeanor charge of the "illegal method of take—shark", which pertains to the laws around fishing for sharks.

Penalties:

• Robert Lee Benac, who was 28 at the time of the incident, accepted a plea deal and was sentenced to 10 days in jail, to be served on weekends. He was also given 11 months of probation and a $2,500 fine.
• As part of his sentence, Benac was required to perform 250 hours of community service, with 125 of those hours to be served at an animal shelter.
• Benac's fishing license was revoked for three years.
• While the charge will appear on his record, the judge in the case withheld adjudication, meaning Benac was not convicted.
• Michael Wenzel and Spencer Heintz were also charged, and Wenzel received a similar plea deal, resulting in 10 days in jail and probation.
• The penalties for this case were decided by the Hillsborough County State Attorney's Office and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC).

The public reaction to the video

The video of a shark being violently dragged behind a speeding boat in Florida sparked outrage and horrified the public. It was initially posted to Instagram by Mark Quartiano, a well-known deep-sea fisherman and self-proclaimed shark hunter in the Miami area, who goes by "Mark the Shark". Quartiano received the video via a direct message from two Instagram users who appeared to be looking for his approval and possibly a wider audience for the footage. He decided to make the video public to raise awareness of such behaviour and to help identify the individuals involved. Quartiano, who has been shark fishing for over 50 years, was shocked by the level of disrespect and evilness displayed in the video, stating that he had "never seen something like that before".

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) took the matter very seriously and worked diligently to identify the individuals involved. FWC spokesman Rob Klepper emphasised that the agency was disturbed by the lack of respect shown in the video for the state's natural resources. Florida Governor Rick Scott also voiced his outrage, stating that "Florida has no tolerance for this mistreatment". The public's patience and support during the investigation were acknowledged by FWC Commission Chairman Bo Rivard, who hoped that the subsequent charges against the perpetrators would send a clear message that such behaviour involving wildlife would not be tolerated.

The three men in the video, identified as Michael Wenzel, Spencer Heintz, and Robert Lee Benac, were charged with multiple criminal violations, including felony and misdemeanour aggravated animal cruelty charges. Wenzel and Benac faced additional misdemeanour charges for using an illegal method to catch the shark. The public's reaction to the video played a crucial role in bringing attention to the incident and holding the individuals accountable for their horrific actions. The case highlighted the power of social media in shedding light on animal cruelty and sparked discussions about responsible shark fishing practices and conservation.

The investigation by the FWC

The video of a shark being dragged behind a boat in Florida sparked an investigation by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC). The FWC took the video "very seriously" and worked to identify the individuals in the video and the location of the incident. The FWC Chairman, Bo Rivard, stated that the FWC appreciated "the patience and support of the public" as they conducted their investigation.

The FWC confirmed that they had identified the individuals in the video but did not release their identities during the ongoing investigation. The FWC spokesman, Rob Klepper, stated that it was "too early to speculate as to what, if any, violations took place in this incident." However, he also expressed disappointment at the lack of respect shown in the video for Florida's natural resources.

The FWC conducted a thorough investigation, including relentless research into the suspects' social media activity and consultations with shark experts. This led to the identification and charging of three men: Michael Wenzel, 21, Spencer Heintz, 23, and Robert Lee Benac, 28. These men were charged with multiple criminal violations, including felony and misdemeanor charges. The charges included two felony counts of aggravated animal cruelty for each man, and an additional misdemeanor charge of an illegal method of taking a shark for Wenzel and Benac.

The FWC's investigation and subsequent charges sent a clear message that this kind of behavior involving wildlife will not be tolerated in Florida. The FWC's hard work during the investigation was recognised by Florida Gov. Rick Scott, who expressed outrage at the video and stated that "Florida has no tolerance for this mistreatment."

The fate of the shark

The shark, visibly struggling and violently dragged behind the speeding boat, faced a cruel and torturous fate. The video shows the shark being thrust into the air, skipping hard on the water's surface, and tumbling over the boat's wake. The shark was caught on a fishing line or rope by its tail fin, a method described in some fishing forums as a way to safely bring sharks aboard. However, in this case, the shark endured immense distress and suffering.

The individuals in the video, excluding the person filming, are seen laughing and smiling, with one of them commenting that the shark looks "almost dead." The shark's fate was in their hands, and they chose to torment and abuse it rather than show any compassion or respect for the animal. The shark's bloodied and torn remains serve as a stark reminder of the cruelty it endured.

The video sparked outrage and led to an investigation by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. The public was horrified and disturbed by the actions of the individuals in the video. Many people expressed their disgust and called for those responsible to be identified and held accountable. The investigation resulted in charges of animal cruelty and other violations for the individuals involved.

While the shark's life was cut short in a cruel and inhumane manner, its fate sparked a movement for change. The incident led to increased awareness, stricter regulations, and a clearer understanding that such behaviour will not be tolerated. The shark's legacy is a reminder that every creature deserves respect and humane treatment.

Frequently asked questions