The Open Boat: Analyzing The Story's Tone And Mood

The tone of a piece of writing is its general character or attitude, and in Stephen Crane's 'The Open Boat', the tone is serious, sarcastic, and sympathetic. The story follows four shipwreck survivors—the captain, the cook, the correspondent, and the oiler—as they struggle to survive in a small lifeboat. The tone is serious as the men are in grave danger of losing their lives, with the sea characterised as empty and thoughts of death ever-present. The sarcastic tone is evident in the absurdity of their situation, such as the mundane and repetitive nature of their survival efforts. Sympathy is evoked as the narrator highlights the men's misery, enduring cold, hunger, and fear. The story's tone is also bleak and reflective, with moments of tenderness contrasted by the indifference of the world.

Bleakness and reflection

The tone of Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" is bleak and reflective. The story opens with the characters' lack of knowledge and the smallness of their boat, setting them up as underdogs with little hope. The sea is described as empty, and thoughts of death are pervasive. The men fear drowning and plead for mercy from the universe.

The story's only optimist, the cook, maintains hope for survival, but his expectations are repeatedly dashed. For example, he believes they will reach a house of refuge or a life-saving station and be rescued, but when they arrive, the life-saving station seems deserted. The story's tone is made bleaker by the sparing use of names, with the men referred to by their professions, reducing them to their utility rather than regarding them as fully rounded characters. The only character given a name, the Oiler (Billie), dies, making his death seem all the more unjust.

Despite moments of tenderness, the indifference of the world makes the tone darker by contrast. The gentleness and brotherhood between the men in the boat are contrasted with the uncaring world around them. The story's tone is also shaped by the serious and sarcastic nature of the narrative, reflecting the absurdity and mundane aspects of the men's survival efforts. The narrator is sympathetic to the men's plight, conveying the tangible discomfort of their situation through reminders of their wet clothes, cold hands, harsh sun, scary waves, aching backs, and empty bellies.

Throughout the story, Crane presents a serious and plausible tone, refraining from sensationalising the dangers faced by the men. He acknowledges the absurdity of their situation while maintaining a sense of sympathy and seriousness. The men's reflections on their potential fate further contribute to the bleak and reflective tone of the story.

The insignificance of humans in nature

The tone of Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" is often regarded as a reflection on the insignificance of humans in nature. This theme is a common interpretation, and it is explored through the harsh and indifferent depiction of the natural world in the story. Here is a more detailed examination of this aspect:

The story, based on Crane's own experience of surviving a shipwreck, places four men in a small dinghy, adrift in the ocean. The men are at the mercy of the vast, indifferent sea, and their struggles to survive are depicted with a sense of grim realism. The power of the natural world is emphasized, with the sea portrayed as an overwhelming, uncaring force. The men are insignificant in the face of this power; their struggles are futile against the might of nature.

This sense of insignificance is heightened by the detached, almost clinical tone that Crane employs. The story is told with a matter-of-factness that underscores the idea that the natural world is indifferent to human suffering. The men's efforts to row toward shore, their battles against the current and waves, and their eventual failure to reach safety are all described with a sense of detachment, as if nature is merely observing the futile struggles of these tiny, insignificant creatures.

The imagery used in the story further emphasizes the insignificance of the men. They are described as "specks" in the vastness of the sea, their boat a tiny, fragile vessel in the face of the powerful waves. The sea itself is personified as a malevolent force, with the waves described as "long and smooth, like vast, slow swaths of rich fabric," yet capable of destroying the men with indifference. The men are but tiny players in a much larger, uncaring drama.

The theme of human insignificance is also reflected in the story's outcome. Despite their efforts, the men are ultimately unable to overcome the forces of nature. They are dashed against the shore, their boat destroyed, and they are left clinging to debris, their survival uncertain. This ending underscores the idea that humans are insignificant in the grand scheme of nature; their lives are fragile and fleeting, subject to the whims of a powerful and indifferent natural world.

Through its stark and unflinching portrayal of nature's indifference, "The Open Boat" serves as a powerful reminder of the small and vulnerable place humans occupy in the natural world. The story's tone and imagery combine to create a sense of detachment and insignificance, highlighting the overwhelming power of nature over the fragile existence of humanity. This theme continues to resonate, reminding readers of the humbling reality of our place in the universe.

The absurdity of the situation

> "When it occurs to a man that nature does not regard him as important, and that she feels she would not maim the universe by disposing of him, he at first wishes to throw bricks at the temple, and he hates deeply the fact that there are no bricks and no temples."

The narrator goes on to describe how, in such a moment of realisation, a man might wish to confront a personification of nature and plead his case, begging to be allowed to live. However, he ultimately recognises the futility of this, as nature is indifferent, "flatly indifferent".

This indifference is reflected in the story's bleak and serious tone. The men are faced with the absurdity of their own insignificance as they battle against the relentless and uncaring sea. Their small boat is tossed about like a toy, and despite their tireless efforts, nature seems determined to destroy them. The sea is described as "grim", "barbarous", and "wrongful", its waves "like rocks" that threaten to swamp the boat at any moment.

Adding to the absurdity is the fact that the men have been in this situation before. They are survivors of a shipwreck, and yet, despite their previous trauma, they have not slept or eaten properly for two days. Their physical exhaustion only serves to heighten the absurdity and hopelessness of their struggle for survival.

The story's sarcasm also highlights the absurdity of the situation. The men's mundane and repetitive efforts to survive are undercut by the narrator's dry humour, as in the following passage:

> "In the meantime the oiler and the correspondent rowed. And also they rowed. They sat together in the same seat, and each rowed an oar. Then the oiler took both oars; then the correspondent took both oars; then the oiler; then the correspondent. They rowed and they rowed."

The narrator's sarcasm continues as he describes the men's increasingly desperate attempts to interpret the signals of a man on shore, who they hope will rescue them. The man waves his coat above his head, and the men debate whether he is signalling them to change course or simply saying hello. The narrator's dry wit underscores the absurdity and futility of the men's situation, as they desperately try to find meaning in something ultimately meaningless.

Brotherhood and camaraderie

The story "The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane centres on four men—the captain, the cook, the correspondent, and the oiler—who are stranded in a small lifeboat in the violent sea off the coast of Florida. The tone of the story is bleak and reflective, emphasising the characters' lack of knowledge, small chances of survival, and the indifference of the world. However, despite the grim circumstances, the story also highlights moments of tenderness and brotherhood between the men.

The men in the boat form a unique and profound bond, a "subtle brotherhood" as Crane describes it, that is born out of their shared perilous experience. They are united by their common goal of survival and develop an unspoken understanding and respect for one another. This camaraderie is especially evident in the way they work together to navigate the treacherous waters and keep the boat afloat. Each man has a role to play, and they take direction from the captain, whose orders are obeyed without question. Even the correspondent, who is described as cynical and sceptical, feels a deep connection to his companions.

The story's description of the men's brotherhood is poignant and moving. Despite their fear and exhaustion, they find solace and strength in one another. They share what little they have, including the correspondent's dry cigars, and they take turns rowing and bailing out water. The oiler and the correspondent, in particular, form a special bond, taking turns at the oars and supporting each other through their arduous task. Their camaraderie is understated but powerful, a quiet understanding that gives them comfort in the face of uncertainty.

The men's brotherhood is also evident in their shared moments of humour and humanity. They joke about the seagull that lands on the captain's head, finding camaraderie in their shared annoyance at the bird's audacity. And when the correspondent and the oiler switch places at the oars, their careful dance to avoid rocking the boat speaks volumes about their trust and reliance on one another. These small moments of connection bring levity and warmth to an otherwise bleak situation.

The brotherhood between the men is a bright light in the darkness of their situation. It gives them hope and strength when all else seems lost. They are united in their struggle, and their shared experience forges an unbreakable bond. The tenderness and compassion they show one another stand in stark contrast to the indifference of the sea and their uncertain fate. This brotherhood is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the power of connection in the face of adversity.

The indifference of nature

As the men battle the relentless waves, they are acutely aware of their smallness and vulnerability. The sea is described as empty, and the men's boat is minuscule in comparison to the towering waves that threaten to capsize them at any moment. The story's tone is bleak and reflective, emphasizing the characters' lack of control over their fate. Despite their efforts to row toward shore, they are at the mercy of the indifferent sea, which seems intent on thwarting their progress.

The men's hopes and fears are juxtaposed against the indifferent natural world. The cook, the most optimistic of the group, repeatedly expresses his belief that they will be rescued, only to be proven wrong again and again. The men's camaraderie and tenderness toward each other stand in stark contrast to the uncaring sea, making their situation seem all the more tragic.

As their situation becomes increasingly dire, the men's reflections on their impending mortality are met with silence from the sea. The correspondent, contemplating the possibility of his own death, feels a sense of injustice at the idea of drowning after coming so far. He questions the "seven mad gods who rule the sea," expressing his anger and frustration at the indifference of nature.

The vastness and indifference of the sea serve as a constant reminder of the men's mortality and the fragility of human life. The story's ending, in which the oiler drowns despite their desperate struggle for survival, underscores the tragic reality of their situation. The sea remains unfazed by their plight, continuing its relentless march toward the shore.

In "The Open Boat," Crane presents a world in which nature is indifferent to human suffering and fate is arbitrary. The men's battle for survival against the relentless sea highlights the insignificance of human life in the grand scheme of things. The story's tone reflects this sense of bleakness and futility, underscoring the ultimate indifference of nature.

Frequently asked questions