The Open Boat's Ironic Ending: Nature's Indifference

In Stephen Crane's short story 'The Open Boat', four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—are stranded in a lifeboat in the ocean after their ship sinks. The ending of the story is ironic because, despite the men's belief that they can now be interpreters of the sea, the story conveys that the universe is indifferent to their fate and struggles, and that there is no meaning in the natural order of things. This is exemplified by the death of Billie the oiler, who is the strongest of the four and the most likely to survive, yet he is the only one who dies, underscoring the futility of their struggles against indifferent natural forces.

The indifference of nature: the sea is indifferent to the men's courage, valor, and brotherhood

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—are stranded in a lifeboat in the vast, indifferent sea. The story explores naturalist themes, depicting the power of brotherhood and survival in the face of an indifferent and hostile natural world.

The sea is indifferent to the men's courage, valor, and brotherhood. Despite their desperate struggle for survival, they are at the mercy of the unforgiving ocean, highlighting their insignificance and helplessness in the face of nature's apathy. The correspondent's frustration with the inability to find meaning or justice in the chaos of the natural world is evident in his statement about wanting to throw bricks at the temple, only to discover that neither bricks nor temples exist.

The men's small lifeboat, meant to bring safety and salvation, becomes a source of danger and suffering. It symbolises their vulnerability and powerlessness against the indifferent sea, serving as a powerful example of irony in the story. The irony is further emphasised by the narrator's continued anthropomorphisation of nature, referring to it as "she", even as the men realise their inability to converse with or interpret it.

The ending of the story underscores the futility of the characters' struggles, as the strongest among them, Billie the oiler, perishes. His death stands in contrast to the survival of the other three men, who are rescued and cared for by a crowd of rescuers bearing gifts of warmth, nourishment, and sustenance.

The final mystery of the story lies in the men's newfound belief that they can be "interpreters" of the ocean's voice. This realisation comes as they comprehend nature's indifference towards them, rather than any malicious intent. The sound of the great sea's voice, carried by the wind to the men on shore, leaves them with a sense of understanding, despite the absence of any inherent meaning or message in the natural order of things.

The men's insignificance: the men are shut out from the cosmos, realising their smallness

The ending of Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" underscores the theme of the insignificance of the four men—the correspondent, the oiler, the cook, and the captain—in the face of the vast and indifferent universe. This theme of existentialism is evident throughout the story, as the men grapple with their smallness and powerlessness against the mighty sea.

The men find themselves in a desperate struggle for survival, but the universe remains indifferent to their courage, brotherhood, and valor. Their appeals to fate and God go unanswered, highlighting the absurdity of their situation and the lack of meaning in the natural order. The correspondent's frustration is evident in his desire to throw bricks at the temple, only to realise that there are neither bricks nor temples, signifying the futility of finding justice or meaning in the chaos of the natural world.

The ending of the story brings this theme of insignificance to a poignant conclusion. Despite their harrowing experience, the men are ultimately unable to converse with or interpret nature. The final sentence of the story, where the narrator notes that the three surviving men feel they can be "interpreters" of the ocean's voice, is laden with irony. By this point, the men have realised that the sea's voice is incoherent and that the universe is a cosmic void devoid of meaning. There is nothing left to interpret.

The death of Billie the oiler further underscores the futility of their struggles against the indifferent forces of nature. As the strongest among them, his demise highlights the powerlessness of the men in the face of the unrelenting sea. The irony of their situation is that the lifeboat, meant to bring safety and salvation, becomes a source of danger and suffering, underscoring their vulnerability and helplessness.

In the end, the men are left with a profound understanding of their insignificance in the grand scheme of the cosmos. The vast ocean, with its indifferent waves, serves as a stark reminder of their smallness and the inherent cruelty of nature. This realisation leaves the men with a sense of existential despair, as they confront the absence of meaning and the indifference of the universe to their plight.

Interpreting nature: the men realise the sea's voice is incoherent and the universe is indifferent

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—are stranded in a lifeboat in the ocean after their ship sinks. The story explores naturalist themes, and the ending is rife with irony.

The men realise that the ocean is not going to be benevolent to them, and the boat, which is supposed to save them, becomes a symbol of their vulnerability and helplessness. The indifferent and hostile sea, represented by the wave, sea, and shark, underscores the futility of the men's struggles against the forces of nature.

The irony in the ending of "The Open Boat" lies in the survivors' interpretation of nature. After their harrowing experience, the three surviving men—the captain, the cook, and the correspondent—feel that they can now be "interpreters" of the sea's voice. However, the true irony is that there is nothing to interpret. They finally realise that the sea's voice is incoherent and that the universe is indifferent to their plight. This realisation drives home the existential view that humanity is insignificant in the universe and that any meaning must be constructed by individuals.

The ending of "The Open Boat" underscores the indifference of nature and the universe to human struggles and suffering. The men's desperate attempts to survive and justify their existence in the face of an uncaring universe highlight the absurdity of their situation. Crane's use of the word "absurd" resonates with the existentialist belief that the universe is inherently meaningless and that any interpretation of nature is ultimately futile.

Human qualities: the narrator continues to give human qualities to inhuman things, such as nature

In "The Open Boat", Stephen Crane employs irony by having the narrator continue to ascribe human qualities to inanimate objects, such as nature, even as the correspondent comes to terms with his insignificance in the face of the universe. This is evident in the narrator's personification of nature as a "she", an inscrutable mistress whose ways are beyond human comprehension. Despite the narrator's attempts to characterise nature with human attributes, the story underscores nature's indifference to the plight of the men.

Throughout the story, the narrator describes the sea using human-like characteristics, such as snarling, hissing, and bucking like a bronco. However, as the men's journey progresses, the narrator's depiction of the sea shifts to reflect its true nature: an indifferent force beyond human understanding. The sea is described as merely “pacing to and fro”, devoid of any malicious intent or consciousness. This change in perception highlights the men's growing realisation of their insignificance in the grand scheme of the universe.

The narrator also attributes human-like qualities to the wind and waves, which are described as having temperaments that shift constantly, without regard for the men's words and actions. This personification underscores the idea that nature is a force beyond human control or influence. The men's attempts to "converse" with nature are futile, as nature remains an inscrutable and indifferent force.

Additionally, the narrator describes the four men in the boat as being "at the mercy of five oceans", emphasising their diminutive size and power in comparison to the vast and powerful nature. The story highlights the men's struggle for survival against the indifferent and often hostile forces of nature. The sea is portrayed as a menacing presence, with waves that growl like wild animals and a shark that cuts through the water like a "gigantic and keen projectile".

Despite the narrator's humanisation of nature, the story ultimately reinforces the idea that nature is indifferent to the struggles and triumphs of humankind. The men experience both the helpful and hurtful sides of nature, from favourable winds to menacing waves. The correspondent's final rescue by a freak wave underscores the indifference of nature, as it may also have been responsible for the death of the oiler.

In conclusion, the narrator's attribution of human qualities to inanimate objects, such as nature, serves as a form of irony in "The Open Boat". While the narrator personifies nature as a conscious entity, the underlying theme of the story is the indifference of nature towards the struggles and triumphs of humankind. The men's journey is a reflection of their growing realisation of their insignificance in the vast and indifferent universe.

The struggle to survive: the dinghy/lifeboat, meant to save lives, becomes a source of danger and suffering

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", four men—a correspondent, an oiler, a cook, and a captain—struggle to survive after their ship sinks, leaving them stranded in a small lifeboat. The irony of their situation is that the lifeboat, meant to be a source of safety and salvation, instead becomes a symbol of their vulnerability and helplessness in the face of the indifferent and hostile sea.

The men quickly realize that the ocean is not going to be benevolent to them. The vastness of the sea dwarfs their tiny lifeboat, which struggles to climb the massive waves. Each crest feels like it could be the one to capsize the boat. The men are packed tightly into the lifeboat, unable to move without risking tipping it over. This sense of precariousness and danger underscores the irony of their situation, as the lifeboat meant to save them only serves to highlight their fragility and powerlessness in the face of the unforgiving ocean.

The correspondent and the cook argue about whether they are nearing a lighthouse and a potential refuge. The cook believes they will be seen and rescued quickly, while the correspondent corrects him, noting that houses of refuge don't have crews, only emergency supplies. Despite their disagreement, the men are hopeful that they will be rescued soon. However, their optimism is tempered by the uncomfortable and confined space of the lifeboat, which restricts their movements and makes them feel vulnerable.

As the story progresses, the men's exhaustion and desperation grow. The oiler, in particular, is exhausted from working back-to-back shifts in the ship's engine room before the ship sank. The captain warns the men to preserve their strength in case they need to swim to shore. The sense of camaraderie and brotherhood among the men deepens as they face the shared struggle for survival. They are angry at the possibility of drowning, questioning why the "seven mad gods who rule the sea" would let them come so close to shore only to perish.

The irony of the dinghy/lifeboat is further emphasized when the men spot a person on shore waving at them. They rejoice, believing they will finally be rescued. However, their attempts to signal back with a makeshift flag made from a bath towel and a stick go unnoticed, as the man on shore is just casually waving at what he thinks are fishermen. This moment underscores the men's isolation and the indifference of the natural world, as they are left to continue their perilous journey.

Throughout the story, the men's struggle to survive is marked by moments of hope and despair. The lifeboat, meant to be their salvation, instead becomes a source of danger and suffering, highlighting their insignificance in the vast and unforgiving natural world. The irony of their situation is a powerful element of the story, as the men grapple with the realization that the universe is indifferent to their courage, valor, and brotherhood.

Frequently asked questions