Rv Antifreeze For Boat Engines: Good Or Bad?

RV antifreeze is a topic of debate among boat owners, with some people swearing by it and others warning against it. The main concern is that RV antifreeze does not contain corrosion inhibitors, which are crucial for preventing rust in engines. However, some people argue that RV antifreeze is safe to use in engines as long as it is propylene glycol-based and does not contain alcohol. This type of RV antifreeze is recommended for winterizing marine engines. On the other hand, some boat owners prefer to use automotive antifreeze, such as Prestone, for its superior corrosion protection. Ultimately, the best antifreeze for a boat engine may depend on various factors, including the climate, the type of engine, and the boat's proximity to bodies of water.

RV antifreeze is not recommended for boat engines with closed cooling systems

RV antifreeze that contains a mixture of propylene glycol and alcohol should be avoided for engine winterization. This type of RV antifreeze lacks anticorrosion additives, which are crucial for protecting engine components from corrosion and rust. Without these additives, your boat engine may be susceptible to corrosion and premature deterioration.

When selecting an antifreeze product for your boat engine, it is important to choose one that is specifically designed for marine engines. Marine-grade antifreeze products, such as those sold by West Marine, are formulated with the necessary anticorrosion additives to protect your engine. These products may be more expensive than standard RV antifreeze, but they are worth the investment to ensure the longevity of your boat engine.

Additionally, it is important to consider the environmental impact of the antifreeze you choose. Propylene glycol-based antifreeze, while more expensive, is a better option for the environment than ethylene glycol-based products. When releasing your boat into the water after winter storage, you will be discharging the antifreeze, so opting for a more environmentally friendly option is beneficial for marine life and the ecosystem.

Finally, it is worth noting that some boat owners prefer to use automotive coolant or marine-specific coolants, such as Sierra coolant, for their engine winterization needs. These products offer freeze protection and may be more cost-effective alternatives to marine-grade antifreeze while still providing the necessary corrosion protection.

RV antifreeze is suitable for winterizing raw water-cooled boat engines

RV antifreeze that contains a mixture of propylene glycol and alcohol is not recommended for winterizing engines. This type of RV antifreeze is intended for use in potable water systems and is often pink or orange in colour. While it can be used to winterize the raw water side of an engine's cooling system, it should not be used in a closed engine cooling system as it does not contain the necessary corrosion inhibitors to protect the engine from rust.

However, regular RV antifreeze that does not contain alcohol is recommended for winterizing marine engines. This type of RV antifreeze is also suitable for winterizing fresh water systems and engine cooling/exhaust. It is important to read the labels of the products as the marketing of these products can be confusing. For example, some RV antifreeze may be labelled as "non-toxic" when it is actually only "less-toxic".

When winterizing a raw water-cooled boat engine, it is crucial to drain all water from the system as much as possible. This can be done by opening the through-hull, removing the impeller, and using a shop vacuum to suck out any remaining water. It is also important to drain the engine block, manifolds, and other components to prevent freeze damage.

In summary, RV antifreeze that does not contain alcohol is suitable for winterizing raw water-cooled boat engines. However, it is important to carefully read the labels and follow the manufacturer's instructions to ensure the product is compatible with your specific engine and cooling system.

RV antifreeze is non-toxic and safer for the environment than automotive antifreeze

The primary components of non-toxic RV antifreeze are either ethanol or propylene glycol, both of which raise the freezing point of water. Ethanol-based antifreeze is less expensive and effective in preventing pipe damage, but it can leave an unpleasant taste in the plumbing system. It is also combustible, so it must be kept away from flames. Propylene glycol, on the other hand, is non-flammable and safer for humans when used as directed. However, it is important to choose virgin propylene glycol products that are not made from recycled chemicals, as these may contain contaminants.

When selecting RV antifreeze, it is essential to consider the climate you'll be operating in. In more moderate climates, a less expensive ethanol-based antifreeze may suffice. However, in extremely cold regions, propylene glycol-based antifreeze is preferred due to its non-flammable and lubricating properties, making it better at protecting plumbing seals. Additionally, propylene glycol-based antifreeze leaves less residual taste and smell, making it easier to wash out of the system.

It is worth noting that RV antifreeze should not be ingested by humans or pets, as it can cause health issues. Always follow the manufacturer's instructions and take precautions during the winterizing process if you have pets. Additionally, ensure proper disposal of RV antifreeze, as it can still harm animals and the environment if it seeps into water sources.

Automotive antifreeze is toxic and can be harmful to animals and the groundwater

Antifreeze is a common additive to engine coolants to prevent them from freezing in cold environments. However, automotive antifreeze is toxic and can be harmful to animals and the groundwater.

Ethylene glycol, commonly found in automotive antifreeze, is a bright-coloured, sweet-tasting liquid that is deadly to both humans and animals if ingested, causing severe kidney damage. It is also highly flammable and should be managed as hazardous waste. Even small amounts licked off a cat's fur after it has walked through a puddle of antifreeze can be harmful.

Propylene glycol, another common ingredient in antifreeze, is less toxic than ethylene glycol and is often labelled as "non-toxic antifreeze". It is used in food-processing systems and water pipes in homes. However, it can still be harmful to animals and the environment.

When choosing an antifreeze for your boat engine, it is important to consider the potential impact on the environment and opt for a less toxic alternative. Some antifreeze products are specifically designed to be non-toxic and safe for use in drinking water systems and food processing. These alternatives may be more expensive, but they can help protect animals and the environment from accidental ingestion or leaks.

Additionally, it is crucial to properly dispose of used automotive antifreeze to prevent contamination of groundwater and harm to animals. Used antifreeze often contains toxic ingredients such as benzene and lead, which can leach into the soil and water if not disposed of properly. Proper disposal methods include recycling or taking the waste to a local transfer station, automotive shop, motor vehicle recycling facility, or a household hazardous waste (HHW) collection event or permanent facility.

RV antifreeze does not contain the necessary chemicals to prevent rust and corrosion in boat engines

While RV antifreeze is a popular choice for winterizing boat engines, it is important to note that it does not contain the necessary chemicals to prevent rust and corrosion in these engines. This is because the freshwater systems in boats and RVs have different components, with boats containing iron and aluminum parts that are prone to corrosion and rust.

RV antifreeze is designed to be used in recreational vehicles, where the focus is on maintaining the integrity of the potable water system, which is usually made of plastic, brass, or copper. As such, RV antifreeze is formulated to be non-toxic and safe for human consumption. While this is an important feature for an RV's water system, it does not provide the necessary protection for a boat engine's unique components.

Boat engines, on the other hand, require antifreeze that can prevent corrosion and rust on steel and aluminum parts. This is especially important for saltwater boats, where the presence of salt can accelerate corrosion. By using an antifreeze specifically designed for boat engines, such as those sold by West Marine, Sierra, or Starbrite, boat owners can help ensure that their engine's components are protected from the elements.

It is worth noting that some RV antifreeze products may contain propylene glycol, which is a better option for the environment than ethylene glycol. However, even these products may not have the necessary corrosion inhibitors to protect boat engines fully. As such, it is always recommended to use an antifreeze product that is specifically designed for marine engines to ensure the longevity and proper functioning of the engine.

In summary, while RV antifreeze may be tempting to use due to its availability and potentially lower cost, it does not contain the necessary chemicals to prevent rust and corrosion in boat engines. Boat owners should invest in marine-grade antifreeze to ensure their engines are properly protected during winter storage and to avoid costly repairs or maintenance down the line.

Frequently asked questions