Cruising Comfortably: Irwin 43'S Bluewater Capabilities

The Irwin 43 is a cruising boat that has received mixed reviews for its ability to handle bluewater sailing. Some owners claim that the Irwin 43 is a sturdy and reliable boat that can withstand challenging conditions, while others argue that it is not suitable for extended bluewater cruising due to issues with hull rigidity and bulkhead integrity. Ultimately, the decision to take an Irwin 43 on a bluewater voyage depends on the skipper's experience, skills, and comfort level with the boat. It is crucial to thoroughly inspect, survey, and, if necessary, modify the boat to ensure it is seaworthy for the intended journey.

The Irwin 43 is a good bluewater cruiser in 5-8 ft seas

Irwin Yachts are known for offering boats that are carefully priced, well advertised, and widely sold to a broad spectrum of customers. However, this has led to a perception that they compromise on the quality of fit and finish. Some people have reported issues with Irwin boats, including problems with the electrical system and false ceilings that make it challenging to chase leaks.

Overall, the Irwin 43 is a good option for those seeking a bluewater cruiser. It offers a good compromise between a bluewater and lite coastal cruiser, with the comfort and space that makes it ideal for liveaboard cruising. While there may be some construction issues to address, with the right upgrades and maintenance, the Irwin 43 can be a capable and comfortable bluewater boat.

The Irwin 43 is not a good bluewater cruiser in 40-knot winds and 4m seas

The Irwin 43 is a heavy boat that offers a good compromise between a bluewater and lite coastal cruiser. It has a spacious interior and decent performance as a coastal cruiser. However, its hidden chain plates and electrical systems are often cited as areas of concern. Overall, the Irwin 43 is better suited for coastal cruising and should not be considered a true bluewater boat.

Those who have sailed the Irwin 43 in strong winds and seas have reported issues with hull flexing and oil canning. The boat may not be able to handle the rigors of extended bluewater cruising and is more suitable for coastal cruising or shorter offshore passages.

When considering an Irwin 43 for bluewater cruising, it is essential to carefully inspect the hull, fittings, rigging, and other critical components. Additionally, be prepared to make upgrades and improvements to ensure the boat's safety and seaworthiness for bluewater passages.

In summary, while the Irwin 43 has its strengths as a coastal cruiser, it is not the best choice for bluewater cruising in demanding conditions. Its limitations become more apparent when faced with strong winds and seas, and it may not provide the necessary stability and durability for extended offshore passages.

The Irwin 43 is a good bluewater cruiser for the Caribbean

The Irwin 43 is a heavy boat, which some say makes it a good compromise between a bluewater and a lite coastal cruiser. It has a displacement of 13 tons, with a ballast weight of 7.6 tons. While some have criticised the Irwin 43's hull construction, citing issues with flex in the hull in big seas, others have praised its robustness. One owner claimed that their Irwin 43 was "big, heavy and comfortable in 5-8 ft seas".

The Irwin 43 is also a spacious boat, with lots of room and a well-laid-out design. However, some have criticised the quality of the cabinetry and the placement of the engine and generator, which they say are hard to work on. Some owners have also reported issues with electricals, and false ceilings that made chasing leaks a challenge.

Overall, the Irwin 43 is a good choice for bluewater cruising in the Caribbean. While it may not be the best boat for crossing oceans, it is well-suited for coastal cruising and has proven to be comfortable and seaworthy in moderate conditions.

The Irwin 43 is not a good bluewater cruiser for the high latitudes

Firstly, Irwin Yachts have a reputation for compromising on the quality of fit and finish to offer boats at more affordable prices for the average boat buyer. This has resulted in constant build quality issues and problems with the electrical systems, engine placement, and hull flex in big seas. One owner reported that the electrical system on their Irwin 42 ketch was "Wal-Mart quality" and had to be entirely replaced. Another owner of an Irwin 44, which has the same hull and build standard as the Irwin 43, confirmed that there is too much flex in the hull in big seas, making it unsuitable for bluewater cruising.

Additionally, the Irwin 43 has been criticized for its thin fiberglass layup compared to similar-aged boats, which could lead to delamination and other hull issues. The placement of the engine and generator has also been described as "terrible" and difficult to work on. These construction issues could become major problems when cruising in the high latitudes, where access to maintenance and repairs may be limited.

Furthermore, the Irwin 43 has been known to have issues with its centerboard pivot, which could fail unexpectedly during a passage. While this may not be a common occurrence, it underscores the potential consequences of some of the Irwin 43's design and construction shortcomings.

Overall, while the Irwin 43 may be comfortable in milder seas, its construction issues, hull flex, and maintenance challenges make it ill-suited for bluewater cruising in the high latitudes. It is essential for prospective buyers to carefully inspect and survey these boats and be prepared for significant upgrades and repairs to ensure seaworthiness.

The Irwin 43 is a good bluewater cruiser for the Pacific

The Irwin 43 is also a good choice for bluewater cruising due to its strong and rigid hull construction. While some concerns have been raised about the quality of Irwin boats, with reports of oil canning and flexing in the hull, these issues are not widespread. One owner reported that their Irwin 43 had plenty of strength and no problem with flexing, even when caught in 25-30 mph winds. Additionally, the fiberglass hull of the Irwin 43 is known to be thick and sturdy, with reports of glass thickness ranging from 1/4" to over 1" in different areas of the hull.

The Irwin 43 also has a well-laid-out interior with ample space, making it a good choice for liveaboard cruising. It offers a comfortable and roomy living space, which is important for extended bluewater cruises. However, it's worth noting that some owners have mentioned issues with the electrical system, galley, and storage space, which may require upgrades or modifications.

Overall, the Irwin 43 is a good choice for bluewater cruising in the Pacific. With its sturdy construction, comfortable handling in moderate seas, and spacious interior, it can provide a safe and enjoyable cruising experience. However, as with any boat, it's essential to have a thorough survey done and make any necessary upgrades or modifications to ensure a safe and successful voyage.

Frequently asked questions