What Defines Boat Docks In Real Property Ownership?

Whether a boat dock is considered real property or personal property depends on the state you live in and the type of home you have. In some states, docks are considered personal property, while in others, they are considered real property. This distinction is important because it determines whether you can finance the construction of a boat dock with a home loan and has different tax implications. For example, in Missouri, a law was passed in 2009 that classified docks as real property, which allowed homeowners to obtain financing for their dock-building efforts. On the other hand, in Texas, a District Court judge ruled that boat docks are personal property due to the temporary nature of the permits given to use them.

A boat dock's status depends on the state and type of home

The classification of a boat dock as real property or personal property depends on the state and the type of home. In some states, like North Carolina, only landowners with single-family residences adjacent to a waterway are granted riparian rights, which allow them to build docks. In this case, docks are considered real property.

On the other hand, condominium owners or those in HOAs may face challenges in having their docks considered real property, as the shoreline is often considered communal. In such cases, docks may be assigned to individual owners but are not considered their real property.

The IRS has ruled that floating docks are personal property for tax purposes, which has created a disconnect with some state-level jurisdictions that classify them as real property. This discrepancy can have significant implications for taxation and financing.

In addition, the status of a boat dock can be influenced by the type of permit or lease associated with it. For example, in Texas, a District Court judge ruled that boat docks with only temporary permits were personal property, while those with long-term leases were considered real property.

It is important to note that the laws and regulations regarding this matter can change over time, and seeking legal advice from a professional well-versed in property rights and local laws is always recommended before purchasing land adjacent to a waterway.

Floating docks can be considered real property

Whether a floating dock is considered real property or personal property depends on the state and the type of home you have. In some states, only landowners whose single-family residence is adjacent to a body of water are granted riparian rights to that body of water, which allows them to build docks.

In the case of marinas, purchasing a slip at a marina is typically done through a membership certificate and does not grant the owner any rights to the land or sea at the marina.

The IRS has ruled that floating docks are personal property, which has created a disconnect with some jurisdictions that classify them as real property. However, in a private letter ruling, the IRS determined that floating docks are considered real property for the purpose of qualifying as "real estate assets" held by a real estate investment trust. This ruling was based on the fact that the floating docks were affixed to the lakebed or seabed and served as a passive function, providing ingress and egress for slip holders to access their boats.

The determination of whether a floating dock is considered real or personal property can have significant implications for taxation, financing, and conveyance when buying or selling a home. It is important to seek legal advice regarding the specific laws and regulations in your state.

A boat dock may be considered an appurtenance

Whether a boat dock is considered real property or personal property depends on the state and the type of home. In some states, docks are considered personal property, while in others, they are considered real property. For example, in Missouri, a law passed in 2009 that classified docks as real property instead of personal property. However, this law only applies to owners of single-family residences and not to condominium owners or homes under a homeowners' association.

The determination of whether a boat dock is considered real or personal property has important implications for financing, taxation, and conveyance when buying or selling a home. If a boat dock is considered real property, it can be financed using a home loan, whereas if it is considered personal property, different financing options may be required.

In the context of a real estate transaction, it is important to understand the concept of "appurtenance." An appurtenance refers to something that is installed in or sits on a property and is considered part of the property, typically passing to the new owners upon sale. Appurtenances are usually permanent additions to the property, made using permanent methods, and their removal would cause significant damage to the property. Examples of appurtenances include exterior buildings, fixtures, oil or mineral rights, and in-ground swimming pools.

In the case of a floating dock that is not permanently attached to real property, an attorney suggested looking at it as an "appurtenance" to the land it served. The dock could be considered an appurtenance if it is used with the land and benefits that land. This interpretation allows for the inclusion of docks that need to be pulled out of the water during winter to avoid damage from ice.

A court ruled that boat docks are personal property

A court ruling that boat docks are personal property can have significant implications for taxation, financing, and real estate transactions. In the case of a Texas lake, a District Court judge ruled that boat docks and boathouses were personal property due to the temporary nature of the permits granted by the water authority. This decision was affirmed by the Appeals Court.

The ruling has raised questions among appraisers, mortgage companies, and local taxation districts, as it contradicts the longstanding treatment of lakefront docks as real property. Personal property, in most cases, is not subject to taxation, whereas real property is. This discrepancy could lead to a refund of taxes for dock owners who have been taxed on their docks as real property.

Additionally, the ruling may impact how mortgage companies fund loans related to boat docks and boathouses. If docks are considered personal property, it could affect the valuation of adjacent real estate, as docks can significantly impact the value of waterfront properties.

The classification of boat docks as personal or real property also has legal implications for riparian rights and public access to waterways. In some states, only owners of single-family residences adjacent to a waterway are granted riparian rights, allowing them to build docks and control access to the physical structure. However, they cannot deny the public access to the water under or around their docks.

It is worth noting that the classification of boat docks as personal or real property can vary from state to state and even between different jurisdictions within a state. For example, in Missouri, a law was passed in 2009 that classified docks as real property, specifically for owners of single-family residences. On the other hand, the IRS has ruled that floating docks are personal property for tax purposes, creating a disconnect with some state and local jurisdictions that classify them as real property.

The lack of uniformity in the treatment of boat docks highlights the complexity of property rights and the need for competent legal advice when dealing with real estate transactions involving waterways.

A boat dock's status affects financing and taxation

The status of a boat dock as real or personal property has significant implications for financing and taxation.

Financing

In the United States, the status of a boat dock can impact an individual's ability to obtain financing for their construction or purchase. For example, in Missouri, before a law change in 2009, homeowners were unable to secure financing from Freddie Mac or Fannie Mae for dock-building because docks were considered personal property. The change in legislation meant that docks were now classified as real property, making it easier for homeowners to obtain the necessary funds for their construction.

Taxation

The distinction between real and personal property also carries differing tax implications. In most states, personal property is not taxable, whereas real property is. This classification can significantly impact the amount of tax owed by individuals with boat docks.

For example, in Texas, a District Court judge ruled that boat docks were personal property due to the temporary nature of the permits allowing their construction. This decision had potential tax implications, as individuals may have been due a refund for taxes previously paid on their docks, and mortgage companies and appraisers would need to adjust their practices.

The IRS has also weighed in on the issue, ruling that floating docks are considered real property for the purpose of qualifying as "real estate assets" held by a real estate investment trust (REIT). This ruling impacts the taxation of REITs, which are required to have a certain percentage of their assets in real estate.

The status of a boat dock as real or personal property is not always clear-cut and can depend on various factors, including the state, the type of home, and the manner in which the dock is attached to the real property. As such, it is essential to seek legal advice to understand the specific implications for financing and taxation.

Frequently asked questions