Basketball Scene: A Recipe For Disaster

how to lose a guy in 10 days basketball scene

How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days is a romantic comedy starring Kate Hudson and Matthew McConaughey. The movie revolves around Hudson's character, Andie Anderson, trying to lose Benjamin Barry, played by McConaughey, in 10 days for a magazine column. One of the most memorable scenes in the movie involves a basketball game between the Sacramento Kings and the New York Knicks, which some viewers have pointed out as a plot hole, as it requires a suspension of belief that the Knicks would be in the NBA Finals. Despite this, the movie is known for its re-watchable value and well-delivered lines.

Characteristics Values
Film Name How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days
Year 2003
Plot Revolves around two people dating. Andie is trying to "lose" the guy in 10 days for her magazine column, and Ben is trying to prove he can make a woman fall in love with him in only 10 days to land an advertising account.
Main Cast Kate Hudson (Andie Anderson), Matthew McConaughey (Benjamin Barry)
Plot Hole The NBA Finals feature the Sacramento Kings and the New York Knicks, which is unlikely.

shunwild

Andie and Ben's relationship

In the 2003 romantic comedy film "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days," Andie Anderson (Kate Hudson) and Benjamin "Ben" Barry (Matthew McConaughey) find themselves in a relationship with ulterior motives. Andie, a writer for Composure magazine, strikes a deal with her boss: if she can successfully hook and lose a guy in 10 days, she can write more substantial stories. Meanwhile, Ben, an advertising executive, wagers with his boss that he can make any woman fall in love with him within 10 days to secure a prestigious diamond campaign.

Unbeknownst to Ben, Andie is the woman he targets for his bet. Andie and Ben embark on a whirlwind courtship, attending a New York Knicks game together early in their relationship. Andie begins to sabotage the relationship by making Ben miss the final shot at the game by asking him to get her a soda, getting him punched at a movie theater by talking loudly, moving girly things into his apartment, and taking him to a Celine Dion concert when he expected to watch the Knicks play. Despite her efforts, Ben sticks around, determined to win his bet.

As the 10 days progress, Andie and Ben's relationship becomes more entangled. Andie behaves outrageously at Ben's boys' poker night, and Ben introduces Andie to his family, forming a genuine bond. They attend the company ball together, where they learn about each other's bets and break up. However, after reading Andie's subsequent article, in which she writes about losing the only guy she ever fell for, Ben chases after her, and they reveal their true feelings and kiss.

Throughout the film, Andie and Ben navigate their conflicting goals, with Andie trying to drive Ben away while he tries to make her fall in love with him. Despite the deception underlying their relationship, they ultimately develop genuine feelings for each other, leading to a romantic conclusion.

shunwild

The Celine Dion concert

The film 'How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days' features a notable scene involving a Celine Dion concert. In the scene, the two main characters, Andie Anderson (played by Kate Hudson) and Benjamin Barry (played by Matthew McConaughey), attend a Celine Dion concert at Madison Square Garden. This scene is significant because it sets up a joke about the Knicks, the basketball team that both characters are fans of.

The joke revolves around the fact that there is a Knicks game taking place at Madison Square Garden on the same night as the Celine Dion concert. However, instead of attending the game, the characters are seen leaving the concert, wearing tour T-shirts. This sets up a twist, as Ben, a sports-loving ad man, would typically be expected to attend the Knicks game. The joke lies in the fact that Ben, who is planning to blow off Andie to watch the game by himself, is unaware that the Knicks are out of town. This twist creates a plot hole that has been noted by viewers, as it doesn't seem plausible that Ben, with his love for sports and the Knicks, would not know about the team's schedule.

The concert scene serves as a memorable moment in the film, offering a break from the basketball-focused scenes while still incorporating the shared interest in the Knicks that was established earlier in the film. This twist in the narrative adds a layer of complexity to the characters' dynamic and sets the stage for further developments in their relationship.

Overall, the Celine Dion concert scene in 'How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days' is a pivotal moment in the film, showcasing the characters' interests, advancing the plot, and providing a light-hearted and comedic tone through the clever use of a plot twist.

Explore related products

Crossover

$3.99

The Way Back

$3.79

Funny Story

$7.82 $19

shunwild

The Knicks game

This scene sets the tone for the rest of the movie, showcasing their shared interest in basketball and the Knicks, which becomes a recurring theme. It also serves as a pivotal moment in their relationship, bringing them closer together and providing a memorable, romantic experience.

However, the scene has been noted to contain a plot hole. After the game, the couple leaves Madison Square Garden, but instead of attending a Knicks game, they are revealed to have been at a Celine Dion concert. This has been pointed out as an inconsistency, as Benjamin's character is portrayed as a sports enthusiast who closely follows the Knicks. It is unlikely that he would mistake a Celine Dion concert for a Knicks game, especially given the significance of the team in the movie's narrative.

shunwild

The NBA finals

Early on in the movie, it is established that both Andie and Ben are fans of the New York Knicks, which is significant because the Knicks are in the NBA Finals. In fact, Andie manages to get her hands on some Finals tickets and takes Ben to a game at Madison Square Garden, which becomes a pivotal moment in their relationship. This particular game features the Sacramento Kings and the New York Knicks, a matchup that requires some suspension of disbelief from the viewers.

However, this scene has also been noted by some viewers as a plot hole. One argument is that if Ben is such a dedicated Knicks fan, he would have known that the team was out of town on the night Andie tricks him into thinking she is going to a game, when they are actually attending a Celine Dion concert. This discrepancy has been pointed out as a break in the movie's internal logic.

Despite this potential plot hole, the NBA Finals scene remains a crucial element in the movie's storyline, contributing to the development of the characters and their relationship dynamics. It also adds to the re-watchability factor of the film, as viewers can appreciate the comedic and romantic elements woven throughout the narrative.

shunwild

The plot holes

The 2003 romantic comedy "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" features several plot holes, particularly surrounding the NBA Finals scenes. Here are some of the identified plot holes:

The Celine Dion Concert

The movie establishes that the characters Andie Anderson and Benjamin Barry are Knicks fans and have tickets to a Knicks game at Madison Square Garden. However, in a notable scene, they are shown leaving a Celine Dion concert at the same venue instead of attending the basketball game. This creates a plot hole, as Ben, a sports enthusiast and Knicks fan, would likely be aware that the team was supposed to be playing that night and not be out of town.

Timeline of the NBA Finals

The movie depicts the NBA Finals as spanning only 12 days, with Ben planning to attend Game 7 on the 13th day. However, in reality, for the NBA Finals to reach 7 games, it would typically take a minimum of two weeks. Additionally, if Games 1 and 2 were played in New York, as depicted in the movie, then Games 3, 4, and 5 would be played in Sacramento, which is not reflected in the film's timeline.

Inconsistent Character Details

The film includes a scene where Ben is surprised to learn that Andie is a vegetarian after he cooks her a lamb dinner. However, this contradicts an earlier scene where Andie eats crab on their first date, indicating inconsistent character details and behaviour.

Unrealistic NBA Finals Matchup

The movie's premise includes the New York Knicks reaching the NBA Finals, which is a significant stretch in itself. However, the notion of them facing off against the Sacramento Kings in the finals is even more far-fetched. This plot point requires a significant suspension of disbelief from viewers.

While "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days" is known for its light-hearted and entertaining storyline, these plot holes have been noted by viewers and critics alike, creating some notable inconsistencies within the film's narrative.

Frequently asked questions

The movie revolves around two people dating — Kate Hudson's Andie Anderson and Matthew McConaughey's Benjamin Barry. Andie is trying to "lose" Benjamin in 10 days for her magazine column, while Benjamin is trying to prove he can make a woman fall in love with him in only 10 days to land a big advertising account.

The movie establishes that both Anderson and Barry are fans of the New York Knicks, who are in the NBA Finals against the Sacramento Kings. This is considered a plot hole as it is unlikely that the Knicks would be in the NBA Finals.

Yes, there is another plot hole related to a basketball scene. In one scene, Andie and Benjamin leave a Celine Dion concert at Madison Square Garden, where there was also a Knicks game happening that night. However, as Benjamin is a big Knicks fan, it is unlikely that he would not know that the team was out of town.

While the movie is considered very re-watchable, it is not considered a cinematic classic.

Some other famous works of the actors in the movie include "The Devil May Cry" anime adaptation (2025) and "Anonymous" (2011).

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment