Recognizing Quality Resin: A Boat Yard Guide

There are three types of resins commonly used in boat yards: polyester, vinylester, and epoxy. Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages, and choosing the right one depends on factors such as the nature of the job, the conditions the resin will be exposed to, and the task it must perform once cured. Polyester resin is widely considered an all-purpose marine resin, suitable for boatbuilding, repairs, and manufacturing various boat parts. It is easy to apply, cures fast, and provides good resistance to UV rays, water, and weather conditions. However, it has weaker adhesion and bonding properties compared to other resins. Vinylester resin offers superior resistance to water penetration and corrosion, making it ideal for hull repairs. It also has better elongation properties, but it is more expensive than polyester. Epoxy resin, on the other hand, is known for its strong adhesion and bonding properties and its ability to bond with a wide range of materials. It is the most expensive option but has a long shelf life.

Polyester resin is a good all-purpose option for repairs

Polyester resin is excellent for fibreglass lay-up, for example, building a boat. Polyester laminating resin doesn't fully cure while exposed to air, so when it is used for lay-up, every application joins the previous one on a molecular level. You end up with a single substance encapsulating multiple layers of glass fabric.

Polyester resin is also a good adhesive, although not as good as epoxy. As a general rule, the tensile strength of a polyester bond will be around 20% weaker than the same bond made with epoxy. However, if the repair will be finished with gelcoat, the laminating or filling needs to be done with polyester, as while epoxy adheres well to cured polyester, the reverse is not true, so the bond between an epoxy repair and an overcoat of polyester gelcoat will not be strong.

Polyester resin is also a good choice for repairs from a cost perspective. Epoxy is three to five times more expensive than polyester. This is relatively insignificant for a small repair, but where the damaged area is large, using polyester resin significantly lowers the cost of the repair.

Vinylester is ideal for hull repairs

When it comes to boat repairs, choosing the right resin is essential. There are several types of resins available, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Vinylester resin stands out as an ideal choice for hull repairs due to its unique properties.

Vinylester resin is a type of styrene-based resin that offers superior resistance to water absorption compared to other resins like polyester. This quality makes it particularly well-suited for hull blister repair. It is also more resistant to corrosion and heat, ensuring that it can withstand the harsh conditions a hull may encounter. Additionally, vinylester has better elongation properties, which means it can stretch more before cracking, resulting in more flexible and durable repairs.

Another advantage of vinylester resin is its strength and durability. While it may not be as strong as epoxy resin, it falls between polyester and epoxy in terms of strength and price. This balance makes it a cost-effective option for hull repairs without compromising on quality. Vinylester is also known for its excellent adhesive and bonding properties, which are crucial for hull repairs. It bonds well with various materials and surfaces, ensuring a strong and long-lasting repair.

The versatility of vinylester resin is also worth noting. It is used for repairs and modifications on all types of boats, from traditional to high-performance vessels. Its durability when exposed to heat makes it a popular choice for manufacturing high-performance boats. Furthermore, vinylester is easy to work with and provides a longer secondary bond window, making it more forgiving during the repair process.

In summary, vinylester resin is ideal for hull repairs due to its superior resistance to water absorption, corrosion, and heat. Its excellent elongation properties, adhesive qualities, and versatility make it a cost-effective and reliable choice for boat owners and repair professionals alike. By choosing vinylester resin, you can be confident in the durability and longevity of your hull repairs.

Epoxy resin is the strongest, but also the priciest

Epoxy resin is widely considered the strongest type of marine resin, offering the strongest adhesion and bonding properties of all resin options. It is also the priciest.

Epoxy resin has been used in the marine industry since the 1980s. It is known for its superior adhesive qualities, bonding to a wider range of materials than other resins, including wood, metal, and cured polyester, vinylester, and epoxy laminates. This makes it a popular choice for boat repairs, especially for older boats that need strengthening. It is also used in the manufacture of new boats.

One of the key advantages of epoxy resin is its ability to resist moisture absorption. This makes it ideal for use in boats, as it helps to prevent water damage. Additionally, epoxy resin has excellent abrasion resistance, further contributing to its durability.

However, despite its strength and versatility, epoxy resin is the most expensive option. In fact, it can be three to four times more expensive than other resins, such as polyester resin. This higher price is due to the superior qualities of the resin, including its strong adhesion and moisture resistance.

The price of epoxy resin has decreased somewhat in recent years due to increased consumer demand for higher-performance boats. However, it still remains the most costly option among marine resins.

Resin type depends on the job, conditions, and task it must perform

When it comes to selecting the right resin for your boat repair job, it's essential to consider the specific requirements of the task at hand. The resin you choose will depend on factors such as the nature of the job, the conditions the resin will be exposed to, and the function it needs to perform.

For instance, if you're repairing an area of fiberglass topside, you might be inclined to opt for the resin with the strongest bond. However, if another resin offers superior UV and water resistance, it may be the wiser choice despite having a slightly weaker bond.

Let's take a closer look at the three most common types of resins used in boat repair: polyester, vinylester, and epoxy.

Polyester resin is considered the all-purpose option and is used for various applications, including boat building, fiberglass repairs, and manufacturing boat hulls, topsides, decks, and moulds. It's easy to apply, adheres well to vertical surfaces, cures quickly, and provides good resistance to UV rays, water, weather, and chemical corrosion. While it ages relatively well, its adhesive and bonding properties are not as strong as other resins, and it's not recommended for high-performance watercraft.

Vinylester resin falls between polyester and epoxy resins in terms of price and strength. It offers excellent resistance to water penetration, corrosion, and heat, making it an ideal choice for hull repairs. Vinylester resin is also known for its superior elongation properties, making it a popular choice for repairs and modifications to all types of boats, including high-performance vessels.

Epoxy resin, on the other hand, is known for its exceptional adhesion and bonding properties. It adheres to a wide range of materials, including wood, metal, and cured polyester, vinylester, and epoxy laminates. Epoxy resin is commonly used for hull or deck repairs, strengthening older boats, and manufacturing new boats. While it is the most expensive option, its price has become more accessible due to the increasing demand for high-performance boats.

When deciding which resin to use, it's crucial to consider the unique demands of your boat repair project. Each type of resin has its advantages and disadvantages, and understanding these will help you make an informed decision.

Polyester is the most common resin used today

Polyester resin has been used to build and repair boats since the invention of fibreglass vessels. It is widely considered an all-purpose marine resin and is used for everything from boatbuilding and fibreglass repairs to manufacturing boat hulls, topsides, decks, and moulds.

Polyester resin is popular for several reasons. Firstly, it is easy to apply and has good adhesive qualities when applied to properly prepared fibreglass. It is also affordable for most boaters, with prices significantly lower than those of vinylester and epoxy resins. Polyester resin is also versatile, with a high viscosity and thixotropic index, meaning it tends not to run or drip once applied, even on vertical surfaces. This makes it ideal for fabricating parts and making moulds of almost any shape or size.

In addition to its affordability and ease of use, polyester resin also provides good resistance to UV light, water, weather, and chemical corrosion. It ages relatively well, although its adhesive, bonding, and stretch properties are not as strong as those of other resins. It is important to note that polyester resin is not recommended for use on high-performance watercraft due to its low stretch (elongation) properties.

When choosing a resin for boatbuilding or repair, it is essential to consider the specific requirements of the job, including the nature of the repair, the conditions the resin will be exposed to, and the task it must perform once cured. While polyester resin is the most common and versatile option, vinylester and epoxy resins offer improved resistance to water and corrosion, making them more suitable for certain applications such as hull repairs.

Frequently asked questions