The Open Boat's Narrative Structure: An Analysis

Stephen Crane's short story 'The Open Boat' is based on his own experience of surviving a shipwreck off the coast of Florida in 1896. The story is told from the point of view of an anonymous correspondent, with Crane as the implied author. The narrative closely resembles the author's experiences after the shipwreck, with four men stranded in a lifeboat in the middle of the ocean after their ship sinks. The story is divided into seven sections, each told mainly from the correspondent's perspective, and explores themes of isolation, camaraderie, and the harsh unpredictability of life.

The story's structure and narrative style

"The Open Boat" is a short story by American author Stephen Crane, first published in 1897. It is divided into seven sections, each told mainly from the point of view of the correspondent, based upon Crane himself. The story is considered an exemplary work of literary Naturalism and is often anthologized. It is praised for its use of imagery, irony, symbolism, and the exploration of themes such as survival, solidarity, and the conflict between man and nature.

The story unfolds through the correspondent's eyes as he and three other men—the captain, the cook, and the oiler, Billie—are stranded in a lifeboat in the middle of the ocean after their ship sinks. Crane masterfully captures their physical and emotional ordeal, reflecting on themes of isolation, camaraderie, and the harsh unpredictability of life. The narrative style is simple and clear, with vibrant descriptions of colour and humour in the form of irony serving in stark opposition to the dreary setting and desperate characters.

The opening line of the story, "None of them knew the colour of the sky", sets the tone for the entire narrative. It establishes a sense of unease and uncertainty, as the men are entirely focused on the waves that threaten to capsize their small boat. The story's structure follows the men's journey, from their struggle to survive in the face of exhaustion and hunger to their fluctuating moods of anger, hope, and brotherhood. Despite their bickering, the men work together to keep the boat afloat, taking turns rowing and bailing water.

As the story progresses, the men's hope for rescue is repeatedly dashed. They spot a lighthouse in the distance but realise the danger of trying to reach it. They see a man on shore who appears to wave at them, but their hopes are crushed when they realise he is simply waving his coat. The structure of the story mirrors the men's emotional rollercoaster, from optimism to despair, as they grapple with the realisation of nature's indifference to their fate.

The story's climax comes when the men resolve to abandon the dinghy and swim for shore. The oiler, the strongest swimmer, takes the lead, but tragedy strikes when he drowns, becoming the only casualty of the group. The story concludes with the rescue of the remaining three men and the sombre realisation of their companion's death.

The characters and their relationships

The short story, "The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane, features four central characters: the correspondent, the captain, the cook, and the oiler. The correspondent is a journalist and the central character of the story. He is intelligent, sensitive, and cynical, struggling with the harsh reality of his situation. The captain, injured during the shipwreck, displays leadership, self-sacrifice, and honour. He is cool-headed and resourceful, feeling responsible for the survival of his crew. The cook is optimistic and cheerful, providing comic relief with his naïve outlook and simple pleasures. He is not fit enough to help with rowing but contributes by bailing water. The oiler, Billie, is the only character with a name and the only one who dies. He is strong, skilled, obedient to the captain, and realistic about their slim chances of survival.

The relationships between the characters highlight human resilience and vulnerability. The correspondent, captain, and oiler form a makeshift crew, with the captain taking on the role of leader. The correspondent and oiler share the arduous task of rowing, while the cook supports them by bailing water. Despite their differences, the men form a "subtle brotherhood" and a deep sense of camaraderie. They rely on each other for survival, and their interactions are marked by mutual trust and support. The correspondent is pleasantly surprised by the warmth of this brotherhood, which stands in contrast to his cynical nature.

The oiler, Billie, has a unique dynamic with the captain. While he staunchly supports the captain's orders, he also serves as a foil to the captain's optimism. Billie is more realistic and down-to-earth, never losing sight of the task at hand. His tragic death underscores the limitations of group benefits and the ultimate responsibility each man has for his own survival.

The cook and the correspondent also have an interesting relationship. The cook represents the world of manual labour and optimism, while the correspondent is a thinker and a cynic. The cook's dreams of rescue are consistently proven wrong, and he serves as a foil to the correspondent's philosophical musings. Despite their differences, they work together to survive, with the correspondent even sharing his dry cigars with the cook.

The themes of the story

"The Open Boat" explores several themes, including the dynamic between humankind and nature, suffering and survival, fate and mortality, and certainty and uncertainty.

Humans vs. Nature

The story centres on the dynamic between humankind and nature, with the four men in the boat—the correspondent, the captain, the cook, and the oiler—representing humankind and their attempts to prevail over nature. Nature, however, has full control over them, and the story makes clear that this control is not due to any particular concern or contempt for the men. Instead, nature is indifferent to their plight, neither conscious of nor indifferent to their struggles. This is reflected in the sea, which is initially described as snarling, hissing, and bucking like a bronco but later merely "paces to and fro," illustrating the change in the men's perception of the sea rather than the sea itself.

Suffering and Survival

The story chronicles the men's suffering as they battle massive waves, endure exhaustion, and contemplate death. It considers what comes out of such suffering, suggesting that hard work and perseverance through suffering do not guarantee survival. However, suffering increases empathy among people, and the men in the boat form a subtle brotherhood, banding together to survive.

Fate and Mortality

The story's characters grapple with the concepts of fate and death, which feel suddenly and alarmingly real to them. It ultimately suggests that humans cannot change their fate, no matter how much they plead or curse their situation. The men's reflections on their own mortality lead them to question their place in the universe and the meaning of their existence.

Certainty and Uncertainty

"The Open Boat" is critical of the attitude of certainty. The cook and the captain embody certainty and uncertainty, respectively, illustrating how claiming certainty is unproductive and foolish. Accepting uncertainty, on the other hand, allows the men to adapt to their situation and take action to improve their chances of survival.

The story's symbolism and imagery

The story is rife with symbolism and imagery, reflecting on the themes of isolation, camaraderie, and the harsh unpredictability of life.

The boat, which is no larger than a bathtub, is a symbol of human life, bobbing along among the universe's uncertainties. It is unprotected and open to the unexpected turns of fortune, much like humans in the context of the world around them. The vastness of the ocean, in contrast to the small boat, emphasises the insignificance and frailty of human life.

The death of the oiler, the strongest and hardest-working crew member, symbolises the indifference and randomness of nature. The fact that he is no more deserving of death than any other crew member highlights the arbitrary nature of nature's whims.

The poem about a soldier dying in a foreign land, remembered by the correspondent, represents his understanding of his own mortality and helplessness. The image of the soldier becomes more significant to the correspondent as he faces his own potential death, giving weight to his own life and a sense of shared humanity with the fictitious soldier.

The imagery of the sunrise and sunset is used to appeal to the reader's senses, creating a sense of beauty and tragedy. The description of the sun changing the sea from grey to "carmine and gold" and the "sunlight flaming on the tips of the waves" emphasises the majesty and power of nature.

The wind tower is another symbol of nature's power and indifference. The correspondent notes its size and serenity, standing "with its back to the plight of the ants", representing the smallness and insignificance of human struggles in the face of nature's might.

The cigars found by the correspondent symbolise hope and spiritual salvation. Four of the eight cigars are dry, coincidentally leaving one for each man. This discovery occurs when the men's cooperation and hard work seem to put them on track to survive, symbolising their optimism. However, by the end of the story, their optimism fades, and the wet cigars illustrate the tragedy and despair of their situation.

The story's context and inspiration

"The Open Boat" is a short story by American author Stephen Crane, first published in 1897. The story is based on Crane's own experience as a correspondent aboard a ship that sank off the coast of Florida in 1896.

Crane sailed out of Jacksonville, Florida, on December 31, 1896, bound for Cuba, to cover the emerging war as a correspondent. His ship sank in the morning of January 2, and Crane and three crew members spent thirty hours in a dinghy before coming ashore near Daytona Beach. Crane wrote a newspaper account of the sinking, titled "Stephen Crane's Own Story", but he shied away from further telling of his experience, writing that "The history of life in an open boat for thirty hours would no doubt be instructive for the young, but none is to be told here now."

Crane waited for years before turning his experience into "The Open Boat." The story confronts both Crane's time aboard the dinghy and the symbolic implications of fighting for one's life amidst forces that are uncaring about one's survival. The correspondent in the story is based on Crane himself, while the injured captain, the cook, and Billie the oiler all have their real-life counterparts in the men who shared the dinghy with Crane. The actual captain did indeed injure himself in the ship's foundering, and William Higgins, the actual oiler, died on the shore.

The story unfolds as the four men face exhaustion, hunger, and the constant threat of the relentless waves. Crane masterfully captures their physical and emotional ordeal, reflecting on themes of isolation, camaraderie, and the harsh unpredictability of life. The critical reception of "The Open Boat" was enthusiastic, with both H. G. Wells and Joseph Conrad praising the story.

Frequently asked questions