Oiler's Fate: Survival In The Open Boat

In Stephen Crane's short story The Open Boat, the oiler, Billie, is the only character who dies. Crane based the story on his own real-life experience in a lifeboat, in which a man named Billy Higgins drowned while trying to reach shore. The oiler is the only character whose name is mentioned in the story, perhaps as a way to memorialise Higgins and to encourage readers to sympathise with the character. The oiler's death underscores the story's naturalist themes, highlighting nature's indifference to human efforts and qualities.

The oiler's death highlights the story's naturalist themes

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", the oiler, Billie, is the only character who dies. Billie is hardworking, empathetic, and the most physically capable person in the boat. He is strong and used to difficult manual labour, enduring hours of rowing in the small boat. He is also the only character with a name, which encourages readers to sympathise with him.

The fact that Billie is the only character to die underscores the story's naturalist themes, highlighting nature's indifference to human efforts and qualities. Billie's death serves as a reminder of the randomness and unpredictability of fate, emphasising that survival is often a matter of chance rather than merit. Nature is depicted as an arbitrary power, acting with indifference to human life.

The injustice of Billie's death is noted by the narrator, who observes that it is an "abominable injustice" to drown a man who had worked so hard. This sentiment underscores the story's naturalist themes, as the narrator grapples with the apparent indifference of nature in the face of human struggle.

Billie's death also serves to subvert the notion of Darwin's "survival of the fittest". Despite being the fittest and strongest of the four men, he dies, suggesting that survival is not based on merit or strength but rather on chance. This further reinforces the story's naturalist themes, as it underscores the powerlessness of humans in the face of nature's arbitrary forces.

Overall, the oiler's death in "The Open Boat" is a powerful reminder of the story's naturalist themes, highlighting the randomness of fate, the indifference of nature, and the powerlessness of humans in the face of its forces.

Nature's indifference to human efforts and qualities

Billie is hardworking, enduring hours of rowing in the small boat. He is also used to difficult manual labour, having worked a double shift in the ship's engine room before it sank. Despite being the most physically capable, Billie dies, highlighting that survival is often a matter of chance rather than merit. Nature is unrelenting and indifferent to human struggles, as captured in the text:

> She did not seem cruel to him, nor beneficent, nor treacherous, nor wise. But she was indifferent, flatly indifferent.

The randomness and unpredictability of fate are emphasised in the story. Billie's death serves as a reminder that it does not matter to nature who is the nicest or the hardest worker. Humans are subject to the caprices of nature, and their actions have little effect on their fate. This is reflected in the following passage:

> When it occurs to a man that nature does not regard him as important, and that she feels she would not maim the universe by disposing of him, he at first wishes to throw bricks at the temple, and he hates deeply the fact that there are no bricks and no temples.

The story also challenges the notion of Darwin's "survival of the fittest." Billie, the fittest and strongest of the four men, becomes the weakest due to his depleted energy from rowing, ultimately leading to his death. This reversal underscores nature's indifference to human qualities, as it is a matter of chance and nothing more that guarantees our safety.

The fact that Billie is the only character with a name further underscores the theme of nature's indifference. By naming Billie, Crane creates a sense of attachment and sympathy for the character, making his death all the more shocking and highlighting the arbitrary power of nature over human life.

The randomness and unpredictability of fate

Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" is a story of four men lost at sea in a small boat. The story is based on Crane's own real-life experience in a lifeboat, where a man named Billy Higgins drowned while trying to reach shore.

In the story, the oiler, Billie, is the only character who dies, despite being the strongest and most capable. This outcome underscores the story's naturalist themes, highlighting nature's indifference to human efforts and qualities. Billie's death serves as a reminder of the randomness and unpredictability of fate, emphasizing that survival is often a matter of chance rather than merit.

The oiler is the only character with a name, which creates a sense of closeness and sympathy with the reader. We are led to believe that Billie, being the hardest worker and in the best physical shape, will be the one to survive. However, his death shocks the reader and reinforces the idea that nature is arbitrary and holds absolute power over human life.

The story's ending leaves the reader with a sense of interpretation. While the oiler dies, the other three men survive, and the reader is left wondering why some lived while others died. The story's philosophical implications highlight the powerlessness of man compared to the mighty and arbitrary power of nature.

In conclusion, the death of the oiler in "The Open Boat" serves as a stark reminder of the randomness and unpredictability of fate. The story's naturalist themes underscore the idea that survival is often a matter of chance, and the power of nature always prevails, regardless of human effort or merit.

The oiler's death is a reminder that survival is a matter of chance rather than merit

In Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat", four men are stranded at sea in a small boat. The story is based on Crane's own real-life experience of being stranded at sea for 30 hours, during which an oiler named Billy Higgins drowned while trying to swim to shore.

In the story, the oiler, Billie, is the only character who dies, despite being the strongest and most capable. This outcome underscores the story's naturalist themes, highlighting nature's indifference to human efforts and qualities. Billie's death serves as a reminder of the randomness and unpredictability of fate, emphasizing that survival is often a matter of chance rather than merit.

Billie is hardworking and physically fit, used to difficult manual labour. He is strong and can endure hours of rowing in the small boat. He works a double shift in the engine room of the ship before it sinks, and once in the lifeboat, he takes turns rowing with the correspondent, speaking very little. He is the most exhausted of the four men, but he is strong, empathetic, and always willing to relieve the correspondent from rowing.

When the men decide to swim to shore, Billie is completely depleted of energy and does not have the strength to make it. His death seems to reverse the notion of Darwin's "survival of the fittest". While Billie seemed to be the fittest and strongest of the four, he used up his energy, which made him the weakest and the most likely to die.

Crane names Billie as the only character in the story, encouraging readers to sympathize with him. We are led to believe that such a character will live: he is good, hardworking, and in good shape. Therefore, his death is shocking and underscores the story's naturalist themes. Nature is completely indifferent to human struggles and qualities. It does not matter to nature that Billie is the strongest and fittest of the men. Nature is unrelenting, and there is always another wave coming to threaten the men.

The oiler's death is an example of Reverse-Darwinism

The death of the oiler in Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" is an example of Reverse-Darwinism, or the non-survival of the fittest. The oiler, Billie, is physically the strongest and most capable person in the boat. He is used to manual labour and has the endurance to row for hours. He is also a leader, taking charge and advising the others as they get closer to shore.

However, the oiler is also the most exhausted of the four men, having worked a double shift in the ship's engine room before it sank. When they decide to swim to shore, the oiler, having depleted his energy through rowing, does not have the strength to make it and dies.

The story thus reverses the notion of Darwin's survival of the fittest. The oiler, who initially seemed the fittest and strongest, becomes the weakest and most likely to die. This underscores the story's naturalist themes, highlighting nature's indifference to human efforts and qualities. Billie's death serves as a reminder of the randomness and unpredictability of fate, emphasising that survival is a matter of chance rather than merit.

Frequently asked questions