Pool Noodles: A Viable Option For Boat Flotation?

Pool noodles are a popular flotation device, but are they effective for boats? While some boaters advocate for their use, citing positive experiences and the convenience of their availability, others warn against it, arguing that pool noodles do not provide sufficient buoyancy to float a boat effectively.

Pool noodles are typically made of closed-cell foam plastic, which prevents water absorption. However, their cylindrical shape means they don't pack well, leaving significant air space around each cylinder. This reduces their overall effectiveness in providing buoyancy.

Additionally, pool noodles may not provide the same level of flotation as the original factory-installed foam, potentially causing the boat to fall short of the USCG reserve buoyancy requirement. They also lack the structural support that foam provides, which helps to stiffen the hull and deck surfaces.

As an alternative, some boaters suggest using plastic soda bottles with tight caps, filled with two-part closed-cell foam, to create a more effective and cost-efficient flotation solution.

While pool noodles may provide a temporary solution, they are not a reliable long-term option for boat flotation.

Pool noodles may become waterlogged

Pool noodles are made of closed-cell foam plastic, which means they are impermeable and do not absorb water. However, some people have reported that their pool noodles have become waterlogged over time, which may be due to the ends of the noodles being cut and exposing the insides, or due to the breakdown of the material over time from sun exposure.

One user reported that their older pool noodles had absorbed water and did not dry out completely, even after a few days. Another user noted that the spray foam they used in their boat restoration had become waterlogged, and that it is important to allow for proper drainage to prevent this issue.

To prevent pool noodles from becoming waterlogged, it is recommended to seal the ends by running a torch over them, especially after cutting them to size. This will singe and seal the open pores, making it more difficult for water to be absorbed.

It is also worth noting that pool noodles may not provide sufficient flotation for a boat, depending on its size and weight. They have minimal flotation value and do not offer the same structural support as foam. Therefore, it is essential to calculate the required buoyancy and distribute the pool noodles accordingly to ensure the boat remains afloat.

They don't pack well and have a hole in the middle

Pool noodles are not a good option for boat flotation as they don't pack well and have a hole in the middle. This means that there is a lot of air space around each cylinder, reducing their effectiveness in keeping a boat afloat. In addition, the hole in the middle means that less surface area of the noodle is in contact with the water, further reducing its buoyancy.

The shape and design of pool noodles mean that they are not an efficient use of space when trying to maximise flotation. Their cylindrical shape means that when placed together, there are significant gaps between them, which can allow water to enter and reduce their overall buoyancy. This also means that more noodles are needed to fill a given space, which can be impractical for smaller boats or those with limited storage space.

The large hole in the middle of pool noodles further reduces their effectiveness as a flotation device. This hole not only reduces the surface area in contact with the water but also creates an air pocket in the centre of the noodle, which can affect its buoyancy. The hole can also trap water, adding weight and reducing the noodle's ability to float.

While pool noodles may seem like a convenient and inexpensive option for boat flotation, their design and shape make them inefficient and ineffective. Their cylindrical shape and central hole mean that they don't pack well and have reduced surface area for buoyancy. As such, it is recommended to consider other flotation options that are specifically designed for boats and can provide adequate buoyancy without taking up excessive space.

They don't provide enough flotation for boats

Pool noodles are not a reliable source of flotation for boats. They are made of closed-cell foam plastic, which does prevent them from absorbing water. However, they do not provide enough buoyancy to float a boat. The amount of flotation provided by pool noodles depends on their volume, density, and weight. In one instance, it took three feet of a 2.5-inch diameter swim noodle to float a 5-pound hand weight. This is a guide, but it indicates that a significant number of noodles would be needed to float a boat.

Additionally, pool noodles are cylinders and do not pack well. There is a lot of air space around each cylinder, and they have a hole down the middle, which means they do not provide as much flotation as foam of the same volume. They also do not provide any structural support to the boat.

Therefore, while pool noodles can provide some extra buoyancy, they do not provide enough flotation to keep a boat afloat in an emergency. It is recommended to use other forms of flotation devices or foam that is specifically designed for boat flotation and meets safety standards.

They don't offer structural support

Pool noodles are not a good idea for boat flotation as they do not offer structural support. While they may be a cheap and convenient option, they are not an effective solution for keeping a boat afloat.

Firstly, pool noodles do not pack well due to their cylindrical shape and the hole in the middle. This means that there is a lot of air space around each noodle, reducing their overall buoyancy. In addition, pool noodles are not designed to provide structural support to a boat. They are not rigid enough to add strength to the hull and deck surfaces, which is crucial for the stability and integrity of the boat.

Secondly, pool noodles can absorb water over time, reducing their effectiveness as a flotation device. Some users have reported that their pool noodles have become waterlogged, even after being left to dry for several days. This can lead to increased weight and decreased buoyancy, potentially causing the boat to sink.

Thirdly, pool noodles may not provide sufficient flotation for larger boats or in the event of a significant breach in the hull. The amount of flotation required depends on the weight and size of the boat, as well as the amount of water that could enter the hull in an emergency. Pool noodles may not offer enough buoyancy to keep the boat afloat in these situations.

Finally, pool noodles can interfere with other systems in the boat, such as the rudder or drainage systems. This can create additional problems and compromise the safety of the vessel.

In conclusion, while pool noodles may be a tempting option for boat flotation due to their low cost and convenience, they do not offer structural support and may not provide sufficient buoyancy to keep a boat afloat in an emergency. It is recommended to invest in proper flotation devices or foam that is specifically designed for boats to ensure safety and compliance with regulations.

They're a false economy

Pool noodles may seem like an attractive option for boat flotation due to their low cost and ease of installation, but they are a false economy. While they can provide some buoyancy, there are several drawbacks that make them a less effective and potentially unsafe choice in the long run.

One of the main issues with pool noodles is that they do not pack well due to their cylindrical shape and the hole in the middle. This means that there is a lot of air space around each noodle, reducing the overall flotation capacity. In addition, pool noodles do not provide any structural support to the boat, which can be important for the integrity of the vessel.

Another concern is that pool noodles can absorb water over time, reducing their effectiveness. Some users have reported that even older noodles left in their pools have absorbed water and do not dry out completely. This can lead to a false sense of security, as the noodles may not provide the expected level of flotation when needed.

Furthermore, pool noodles may not meet the required safety standards for boat flotation. The USCG requirement, for example, is only for manufacturers, but it is important to consider the safety implications of using sub-par flotation devices. In the event of an emergency, inadequate flotation could put lives at risk.

While pool noodles might seem like a cheap and convenient option, they are not a reliable long-term solution for boat flotation. It is better to invest in proper flotation devices or materials that are specifically designed for this purpose, such as closed-cell foam or float bags. These options may be more expensive upfront, but they provide greater safety, durability, and peace of mind in the long run.

Frequently asked questions